Customer Reviews Florsheim Berkley Penny Loafers

Break-in required - Very good looking shoe. I had to order three different sizes before I got the right one. I actually ended up wearing one size smaller than 'usual'. Several weeks of break-in were required. But now they are just fine. Had I gone with my usual size I'd have been swimming in them.

Satisfied customer - The shoe has a great traditional look and is well made. It fits a bit loose in the heel and slides just a bit, but overall comfort is good.

A Tried and True - This is a shoe my husband has been wearing for years. We could not find this shoe in Charleston SC and he was shopping from Lenox Mall in Atlanta. I was so please to find this at Zappos for him. I purchased two pair. Believe me that will last him for quite a while.

Penny Loafers - The service was excellent! I really liked being able to look at the shoe from all different views. I got them the next day without a hitch!

Good - I chose a shoe that could be used for work and for social occasions. I did not want to spend a lot of money. I'm happy with my choice.

Good shoe - Was very please with the purchase. Somewhat small to size, nice lookin, and built like a battleship.

Stiff - Shoe is a little too stiff. Will require a longer "break in" period than I anticipated. With the narrow foot I have, it makes it difficult to keep my heels in the shoes while I'm walking. Would have preferred a softer soul.

Great Value! I've purchased lots of penny loafers in the past and usually paid far more than these and they weren't any better or fit any better. I liked them so much I bought several more pairs. I'm a long time Zappos customer and aside from reviewing these shoes I can’t say enough good things about Zappos . . . they're my shoe store.

Great shoe for the price. I purchased 15EEE and am grateful that Florsheim makes such a good shoe in this size and width. The shoe is comfortable, true to size and looks great. I just wish it were a little less expensive.

Not perfect, but the best I've found - Unlike the Rockport’s I tried, these were comfortable right out of the box, and they look great. Their fatal flaw is the leather soles. I almost slid down the stairs 5 minutes after putting them on. Even after roughening them on concrete and wearing them for 2 weeks they are still quite slick, and I have had several other slips. I much prefer rubber soles, but none that I tried with rubber soles had a fit or look that I was happy with.

My New Loafers - I received them in 3 days and they were exactly what I expected. A very fast delivery and the price was reasonable.

Good Buy - Stores in south Florida don't carry narrow sizes, so Zappos is a life-saver. This is a very good shoe and the price is right. Normally, I like to try on shoes before I buy. This fit perfectly. It's a little stiff to start with, but that will work out in time.

Shoe return - I am returning this shoe because it's a little too narrow. I do like the look and I hope that you offer a shoe that's a little wider.

Good looking shoes - These shoes look great and feel comfortable after they get broken in a bit.

Good, not great. Comfortable, light, durable, easy on-and-off shoe that works with casual or formal dress. Doesn't offer a lot of all-around foot support but neither does it feel tight in any part of the shoe. Not a good bet for wet pavements because of porous leather soles. Definitely a worthy pick-up if it's on sale.

Traditional preppy penny loafer- A great American permanent fashion, with the "beef roll" on each side of the penny strap. Modest price. Good value. Not much more than repairing your old ones.

Not too shabby- I am still in the process of stretching them out so I can't be 100% on my feedback. As of now I feel that they are not as comfortable as I thought they would be, but they are really nice looking. I can wear them all day without being in pain, but there is a slight discomfort. They were however true to size, but are a little narrow.

Size is close- A great looking shoe, and I'm completely satisfied with my Zappos buying experience. Just seemed a bit big, and all of my Florsheim's at 7.5 eee.

Loafer - Very nice shoe, I've been wearing them for a least the last 10 years.

A Durable Shoe that Looks Good - I have a pair of Black Florsheim's Berkleys that I purchased over 10 years ago and I still wear them after a few re-soles. That is why I purchased a second pair but in cordovan. They are a little stiff but are breaking-in each time I wear them. Very comfortable.

This is more than a penny loafer. It is a classy looking shoe. You can wear it with a suit, or Dockers, and feel comfortable. The shoe runs a little wide in the heel, but true fit in the toe. I had to use a insole to take up the difference. But, I have a narrow foot.

First-time experience with Zappos - Very attractive shoes. It is hard to find narrow shoes and Zappos had them in the size and color I wanted. We even got them much faster than anticipated. The price is very competitive. The shoes are comfortable and didn't take long to break them in.

Good shoe; have bought them before

Penny Loafer - I like the look and quality of the Florsheim Berley but my shoe size 10B was a little too big for the first time in 20 years.

Polish - Not enough polish on leather, tung appears thinner than previous florsheim models.