Customer Reviews Florsheim Berkley Penny Loafers

Very pleased with the quality of this shoe. I wear a narrow size that can be difficult to find. These fit perfectly. They are leather soled so they are a bit slippery. It would be nice to have something with a bit more grip.

My previous penny loafers wore out. Bought them in 1995 at a brick and mortar store in a department store. Had them resoled 1 time. Hope these shoes last just as long.

The shoe seems well made however it's not perfect. For wide footers/flat feet it's not a great shoe. I bought my TTS in Nike/Jordans of 12 in regular width. It seems to flair out on the sides indicating it should be wider. It feels like I needed a 11.5 wide rather than a 12 normal.

I bought the shoe because I still own a 12 B 611 01804N6 shoe that I believe is a Florsheim that I purchased from my union back in the 80's I believe. They are the most comfortable shoe I have ever owned and now I wear it on special occasions, so I was looking for a replacement. I bought a 12 B, however the heel is loose which means my heel is still an A. Anything I can add to tighten up the heel?

These are very nice shoes and are worth the money but I wish Florsheim did not market these as "Burgundy." I purchased them through a retailer with the expectation that they would have a red oxblood/wine/cordovan/burgundy tone to them as the online pics indicate. These do not have a red tone to them and are really just a dark coffee brown.

I was well aware that this shoe was unlined. I wanted an all-leather shoe so I wouldn't suffocate my feet. I failed to comprehend this meant no meaningful arch support. If someone really needs that kind of support, the Berkley Flex may be a better option. Otherwise, I like the shoes and will keep them.

Sizing of the Berkley loafers, was impossible. My narrow foot very comfortably fits a pair of 8 1/2 Alden Cordovan Saddle Oxfords and my Florsheim Imperial Shell Cordovan Wingtips in size 8 1/2 C that I wore 20 years. But these shoes did not fit with either 8 1/2 D or E.

The color is brown chocolate not burgundy

Just received 2nd pair of beautiful "beefroll" burgundy loafers today. Sadly, my feet are old and the shoes didn't fit again.

I've had a pair of these before. Nice basic cordovan penny loafers. I ordered my regular size and the regular width was way too narrow so I had to send them back. I don't need a "wide" shoe in anything else so I'm not sure why these ran so narrow but customer service was very accommodating in exchanging for a wider size.

I've had a pair of these before. Nice basic cordovan penny loafers. I ordered my regular size and the regular width was way too narrow so I had to send them back. I don't need a "wide" shoe in anything else so I'm not sure why these ran so narrow but customer service was very accommodating in exchanging for a wider size.

Quick delivery. Fits great. Nice and shiny. Billy

Quality classic penny loafers with a true to size fit. Goes wit any style, looks great with jeans or dress pants Niw ordering an additional pair!

I have owned a lot of Florsheim shoes. Never expected what I got. Will never order from Florsheim Shoe Company again. No place to upload pictures.

These replaced an exact pair I had. I wore them, repaired the soles and the heels a couple of time but after 20 years it was time for a replacement. They are just like the originals thanks

Hi. I lament that I am not happy with the purchase. They were too large. Unfortunately, I had placed a anti-slide pad on the shoe before I realized it and when I took the pad off, it left a mark from the adhesive. I tried to take the adhesive mark off with water and the coloring in the sole bled a bit. I have not worn them yet, but I do not feel comfortable returning them because of the sole issue.

These look fantastic right of the box, great shine and comfortable to the foot. Love them. My only negative is that I wish they were US made not from India.

I will only buy and wear Florsheim.

The shoes look great, I can tell that they are quality in comparison to other loafers. Just beware of the size they fit VERY slim, no matter the size.

The shoes look great, I can tell that they are quality in comparison to other loafers. Just beware of the size they fit VERY slim, no matter the size.

I have been wearing "Penny Loafers" as my choice of dress shoes for nearly 60 years all the way back to high school. Florsheim is the only shoemaker that still sells the traditional penny loafer under the Berkley style name. Had them delivered about a month ago and were exactly what I wanted.

I have been wearing "Penny Loafers" as my choice of dress shoes for nearly 60 years all the way back to high school. Florsheim is the only shoemaker that still sells the traditional penny loafer under the Berkley style name. Had them delivered about a month ago and were exactly what I wanted.

I had to return the shoes. Florsheim handled the purchase, shipment and return just as they said they would While this purchase was smooth and easy, the experience of having to return the shoes kind of turned me off to purchasing shoes on the internet. Not Florsheim's fault, just too much of a hassle.

I had to return the shoes. Florsheim handled the purchase, shipment and return just as they said they would While this purchase was smooth and easy, the experience of having to return the shoes kind of turned me off to purchasing shoes on the internet. Not Florsheim's fault, just too much of a hassle.