Customer Reviews Trotters Liz

Runs long and loose.

I absolutely LOVE!!! this shoe. It is one of the most comfortable shoe I have ever owned. Beautiful colors and refreshingly stylish! I have it in 5 colors. Unfortunately after 4-5 wearing each pair stretched out of shape to the point of flopping painfully on and off my foot. I am a dedicated 12W and a shoe becoming too wide is saying a lot!!

These shoes are SO PRETTY! I really wanted them to fit! Unfortunately, they were just too narrow. Granted, I have wide feet, but I ordered them in extra wide (EE/WW), and they were still narrow. This is the third model of shoe I have bought from the Trotters line, and all of them have been too narrow, so I guess the Trotters line of shoes is not good for me. I'm so thankful for Zappos! I wouldn't be able to keep looking and trying to find the right shoe if not for their generous shipping policies.

Very pretty shoe but seems to run small. The toe came to more of a point than I had anticipated so that was part of the reason it didn't fit me properly. Also, I have a very narrow foot and this shoe was too tight across the instep.

I have a high instep and found that part of the shoe a bit restrictive. The 9.5 medium also felt a little narrow, but I figured with some wear they'd loosen up. I really liked the appearance and quality, but the deal breaker for me was I found myself repeatedly having to pull up my socks, which kept working their way down under my heel. Never had this problem with other shoes.

Toe bed too narrow. Other than that a beautiful shoe. Will be sending back.

The shoes I received looked nothing like this picture. Not weaved, just smooth leather, the tops have a seam in them sectioning them off from the rest of the shoe and they look nothing like these. I think they sent me the wrong shoes. :(

These are by far the most painful, torture device shoes I have ever owned. 2 years later, I have given up on them because they still give me blisters. They were smart looking and the bone color would go with everything, but I getting older now and I refuse to hurt myself with shoes anymore. I have a normal foot... No special considerations.

Too narrow for my foot, but suspect they will stretch over time; beautiful color. I needed a higher heel unfortunately!

The first day that I wore these I ended up with large blisters on both heels. I do not know when I last had blisters with new shoes. I wear a 12 or 13 medium depending on shoe style. The pair I ordered was a 13M. These shoes are quite stiff and unforgiving. Thank you to Zappos for your awesome return policy.

I was disappointed with this shoe. The bottom was not leather, not rubber...plastic? Not sure. I found very little arch support, and the W was not really wide enough for my foot. I have a wide foot and a narrow heel. Even with a size adjustment, they just had to go back, and I was sad because they are a very good looking shoe. My suggestion, in case anyone at Trotters is asking, add a leather sole and softer leather upper. It may cost a bit more, but I would gladly pay the extra price.

I like the shoes overall. It's better than a ballet flat in terms of style (loafers give a menswear swag to a girl) and has a great finish, slight shine and inner lining. But did not find them as perfect as reviews had suggested. To begin with, one of my feet fit better than the other length-wise (and this is not a usual issue for me). Thus, one of my feet will occasionally slip out. Secondly the shoe gaps width-wise when walking. One of my feet also hurt at the top on longer wear. So it's a right-left inconsistency. Last, the sole has poor grip and makes the shoe rather slippery. My hope is that it will get better with time as my foot adjusts to the shoe especially as I intend to use it as my primary shoe for running errands.

Way too narrow/tight. I ordered a half size up and was shocked that I couldn't get my foot in the shoe. I've never had to order up in width but will try that now to see if it makes a difference. It is a cute shoe though.

Ordered this shoe hoping it was as comfortable as the last Trotters I ordered. Not the case. Length was too long (ordered same size as last order) and the toe area was narrow in the width and height despite stating that they were a WW. Liked the look but very uncomfortable.

I love the leather but they were a little too manly looking. I ordered two different styles of Trotters shoes. This style shoe had to be at least one if not two sizes large. Order down for sure!

Liz a good-looking, versatile shoe. Because my first pair, in size 9.5N, were stretched out and slipping at the heel in the second season, I ordered a new pair in size 9.5S. I was very disappointed when the heels on the narrower pair were slipping at the end of the first day that I wore them. Shoes in narrow widths should have heels that are narrow enough.

Seems to run a little wider than a normal "narrow" or AA. I tried the AAA and it was too tight. Order both if you're in the narrow foot category. I like the styling.

So cute, but so narrow. I usually wear a slim and have super flat narrow foot. These were too tight. Will exchange and try again.

I bought this shoe in two colors and the purple is snugger than the red, go figure. The red is very comfortable the purple less so, if I had tried on at a store I would not have bought it. I wear its okay, the red is better but I question the durability.

I bought 4 shoes at the same time and loved this the most, the fit is great but I must question the durability. The little scale design thing is coming up on the toe already and I just wear it to the office so I'm not sure I can recommend.