Customer Reviews Eastland 1955 Edition Classic II

Good looking, very comfortable. However, they really don't have much support, and I have developed a hot heel so I cannot wear them at the moment. Despite that, I would order them because I like the looks and the feel of them.

These loafers are a reminder of my high school years of wearing penny loafers. Most of all they are well made. They do not have a good arch support but I made sure they were sized so that I could add an insert. I love them and will enjoy wearing them. Thank you Zappos for making shopping with you so easy and returns are easy as well. I never stop trying, if one doesn't work, I just return them and try another, easy as pie. Thank you again.

Love these shoes. Very, very comfortable. No break in period. Classic design. Perfect with jeans.

These shoes are relatively comfortably and served the purpose (I wanted some brown loafers). They're certainly not as comfortable as Bjorns, my usual choice of brands.

These are nice shoes. In fact, I am wearing them right now. Yes, they are narrow, and you should go 1/2 size smaller or they will be too long. They don't have arch support at all, but if you wear them in an office they are very comfortable. The insert does not go all the way to the toes, but the seam does not bother my feet. They have nice stitching and look great. I would recommend them.

I LOVE these shoes! Very comfortable and a great shoe for people on their feet all day. (However, not much arch support, so if you have flat feet, these probably aren't for you.)

Shoes for comfort but definitely strictly for work - While I enjoy the shoe for its comfort value, I would have to say that it is not the best looking shoe. I wish it had a little more style to it.

Eastland Classic Comfort - The shoe runs a little larger than actual size, but for the most part, seems to be a great product and customer service was outstanding. Response time to inquiries/shipment was phenomenal... thank you!

Eastland Classic II - After trying on the shoe, I felt that the shoe was a slight larger than the marked size, which caused me to grab a thick pair of socks to wear with the shoe.

Frequent Customer - The Eastland Classic II is just that; a very classic looking loafer. It's a great shoe for both office and running around on the weekend. It could use a bit more arch support, but otherwise, no complaints. I'd buy them again.

A classic shoe, difficult to size - I had to order three pairs to figure out the right fit! I think it is the narrower toe box that might complicate sizing.

Returned these due to sizing. I wear a size 8 and it felt like I needed a size 9 wide. I could barely get my foot in this shoe.

I ordered my usual 7 wide size. To say that these shoes are too small is an understatement. I literally could not even get my feet into the shoes at all. I’m not sure if even one size larger would be enough it may require two sizes up since as I said they were not just too tight but I could not even get my feet in the shoes

Very tight around the top of the foot, just before where the toes start. Definitely size up. Im a size eight and these were s n u g. Like no socks, maybe stockings.. Also squeaked on the floor while I was trying them on, that may fade with wear but idk. Felt very well made, looked very nice. Sending them back for a bigger size.

The loafers had plenty of style, but one shoe felt a half size smaller. The width was fine but my heels flopped around when I walked. These shoes were not consisted in size with each other. I'm sorry I had to return them.

Did not like how this shoe looked - just lacked style. Not what I was looking for.

heel slipping out when walking

I was disappointed that the shoes were way too big. I will be returning them for a smaller size.

These shoes are designed for a very straight feet. They were too wide for my heel and too narrow for the ball of my foot. Otherwise, they appear to be well-made, but I chose to return them because they didn’t fit well.

It was too big, exchanged for a 6.5.

Sort of cute and functional for casual wear but no support. Felt flimsy.

The color on the website was not representative of the actual color. It appears as a light tan but it is actually a dark brown.

Fit was poor. I have to return them, but there is a problem I have never encountered before with Zappos. The shoes arrived in a box that had a paper inside that said it had been repacked because it had been damaged. There was no sales slip or return slip. Not sure what I should do to return! Need help!

This is a very nice shoe but just didn't fit my foot properly. It was slightly too big and it had a gap on the inside edge that didn't look right on my foot.