Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Amherst 2.0 Knit Plain Toe

Great products Clunky website interface

Beyond comfortable and stylish!

It's obvious to me that no one with any girth tested these bad boys out. They're very comfortable, very breathable, and stylish for most of my casual day-to-day wear. But the suction cup thing is absolutely mind-blowing. I know I'm a bigger dude but having these things pop every time I'm on a tile or wood floor is unreal. Honestly, I would venture to guess if you're over 220 lb then they're going to turn into plungers on you and I would recommend staying away for the sheer embarrassment of the CVS aisle alone!

My new Amherst 2.0 are very comfortable and look great. They fit perfectly right out of the box. The materials are light and breath comfortably here in the Houston, TX hot temperatures. This was my first purchase at J&M, but it certainly wont be my last. The customer service and shipping was terrific.

First Day wearing them nice and comfortable compliments on them as well.

The shoes never disappoint also on point

Bought these as a Father's Day gift for my dad. After putting the shoes on he said he didn't know anyone made shoes that felt that good. He and I both have spent at lot of time on our feet and our shoes have to be very comfortable. I myself have 2 pair of these shoes and I love them too.

Love the shoes. Comfortable and very stylish!

True to most other reviews I read about these shoes, they fit comfortably and run true to size. They're not quite as breathable as I would have hoped, but my hot-running feet feel at a comfortable temperature when wearing these. Like others mentioned, the shaping of the sole leads to suctioning to smooth or wet floors, but I personally don't mind quite as much as others seems to. The color is exactly as it looks online, so no surprise there. Overall, if you don't think the suctioning will bother you, I would definitely recommend.

Fits great. I had to go half a size smaller - no socks. Like walking on air! I get many compliments on them!

The look and fit are great. Look the material and is a great summer look. I have several pairs of JM shoes and they never disappoint

Comfortable and stylish with a roomy toe box. Perfect for the summer weekend get together.

This shoe needs a finger pull at the end.

I really like the look and comfort of these shoes, but there is one issue... The design of the sole bottom creates a suction cup effect when walking on smooth surfaces. You'll hear your shoes popping as you walk along.

The shoes are very comfortable

Comfortable Fit

The shoes fit perfectly!! Had to return them though because of the horrible suction cup noise. Someone really messed up the design. Too bad , because its a good looking shoe. But that sound is annoying!!

I actually look to the opportunities when I can wear these shoes. Lightest lace-up shoe I have ever owned, they breathe really well to keep my feet cool, were extremely right out of the box(I wore them for a dinner the day I received them), and I the style. Also extremely versatile with outfits. I have planned my fits around these shoes, which I have NEVER done before for a pair of shoes. HIGHLY recomme d these shoes!

Great shoe. Perfect for a casual night out

Very comfortable, slip on.

Comfortable out of the box and good looking.

Comfortable and stylish. Dress up or down.

This shoe runs large and the fit is aweful . Not worth the price , no foot support ,very wide and loose.

As a former soldier with a true appreciation for uncomfortable footwear, I will say these shoes are by far the most comfortable shoes I've ever owned; without sacrificing the elegant sporty look. I even gifted a pair to my best friend who is a chef, and he happened to agree!

Love the shoes look and feel great!!