Customer Reviews Birkenstock Mayari - Nubuck Leather

This shoe seemed short to me. I wear a 9 1/2, and my toes were at the very end of the 9-9 1/2. Also, they are very stiff with a hard ridge right behind the toes that hurt with every step I took. These are going to be returned.

As always Birks are comfortable and very supportive. Unfortunately Zappos’ quality has been horrible lately. These had globs of glue all over them and the footbed was damaged. I returned and ordered directly from Birkenstock. I also got oiled leather instead of Birko-flor. I didn’t like those at all. I will not be ordering Birks from Zappos anymore. Too many used and damaged shoes sent. And I mean VERY used! Toe prints and all.

the right shoe was much tighter on the toe - much more cheaply made than my other birkenstocks

Fit and size were fine. I have purchased numerous pairs of these sandals from Birkenstock. This pair....hard as a rock. They are uncomfortable. I am hoping they will soften with time. Disappointed.

Really wish all Birkenstocks came in narrow size options! These are beautiful, I love the antique lace color, unfortunately I have a narrow foot and these just look ridiculous. The Mayari in narrow sizing fits perfect!

I wore them around the house for a couple of hours and they still hurt my feet.

They are hard as a rock they should form to my feet but I don't think I will be able to wear them enough for that to happen. And I ordered regular width they are a little wide I can deal with that. I am so disappointed my fake ones are really comfortable.

The toe loop trapped my toe and my feet said "no way."

I've never owned a pair of Birks, so I decided to see what all of the hype is about. I loved the style of the Mayari, but it felt like I had two cement blocks strapped to my feet. Yes, they conformed and provided support, but there is no cushion whatsoever. My feet hurt after just walking around my house in them. I have more comfortable sandals that I paid $30.00 for. I am returning them.

WOW....What has happened to Birkenstock...?? I have been wearing this brand for years - always great construction/great quality. Not anymore. Materials used are cheaper quality. Some of the glue sites are done wrong. The footbed feels different from shoe to shoe. Really surprising. And REALLY disappointing. Going back...

The interior toe strap placement is just worn for my feet. I have been trying to break them in walking in our house. Hasn't worked. They still rub the wrong way.

These were somehow too big and too small at the same time. They were barely wide enough for my feet and the strap wouldn't buckle because it wasn't long enough, but the sole had an extra inch of space at the heel so they looked like clown shoes and I couldn't wear them. It is a shame because I like the style and the cork feels like quite a comfortable material... Birkenstock says their regular width accommodates wide feet but I can say that isn't true - at least not for my feet because if I sized down to make the length fit, the width would be too narrow. But who knows, maybe Birkenstocks just aren't right for my feet.

They were too big and the leather was very stiff. I sent them back and got a size 36 Salina which fit perfectly. A 37 is too big for a size 6. They were a pretty color though, just didn't work out.

These were immediately very comfortable. Unfortunately, the toe loop on the right sandal came out of the sole today. I got two months of wear making these a little pricey.

I only wore these sandals for 2.5 months and the heel is already falling apart.

The shoe is really cute and fit well. I wear an 8.5 and the 39 was perfect. However, the shoe had already been worn enough that it had someone else's toe imprints and had also obviously begun to form to that person's foot-yuck. It also didn't come in the original box. I'm sending back to exchange for the exact same shoe and am hoping that Zappos actually sends me a pair of "New" ones.

I have wide feet and high insteps and could barely get these on, so they were unfortunately very uncomfortable.

The adjustable toe straps were defective in that they are too short. This style is just not comfortable for my foot.

The strap by the toe is glued weird and pushed in on big toe of both shoes. Really uncomfortable. I think it is because they are made from the faux material, as the leather ones are not like that.

These were an exchange item after my first pair was too big I my usual size. They fit great, like a glove. The thing is: they sent me used shoes! There were dark brown gummy specs worn into the foot beds and toe prints worn in as well. Whoever tried these on and returned them before me wore them extensively. To top it off there was animal hair on them as well. Ew. I usually have great experiences with Zappos but this was lackluster for sure. I love their return policy but I guess some people abuse it (or don’t wash their feet).

The iced poppy color is so summery, and the style of the Mayari is so cute, and I really wanted to love these sandals, but they just weren't comfortable and made a strange suction sound when I walked coming from the area around the arch. So sad!

The fit and color were perfect. Sadly they were returned because the strap around the big toe was way too long on one shoe.

Color name and pics are confusing. I wanted red shoes and this mayari kept appearing. But the color leans toward pink…maybe watermelon. I love the mayari style and fit but am sending this shoe back because of the color. it’s definitely not red.

I so wanted to be like the over 4 thousand five star reviewers but alas, my feet thought these were very uncomfortable. The buckle on the right and left sides of my feet rubbed, so were unwearable for that alone, but the the leather was stiff and not supple as I expected. The sandal base was stiff and unforgiving. Nope, not made for my feet. They are so iconic, I wanted to try a pair. Guess I'll keep looking...

they broke after 2 months! ?