Customer Reviews Birkenstock Mayari - Nubuck Leather

Great fit. Comfortable immediately. Love Birkenstock. Wear them to the exclusion of everything if at all possible.

These sandals are very comfortable, but just not the look I wanted. I know they're sandals, but there's just a bit too much foot showing. I might have liked them if the straps were a bit wider.

Nice arch support had to size up one size love them

First, let me begin by giving a shout out to Zappos for their excellent customer service! Their exchange/return process is outstanding and their staff is top notch! In regards to the Birks, I did find them to run about one size larger. Now that I have the correct size, I am in love with them!! I definitely see myself getting the same pair in another color. They are stylish and so comfortable - I find them to be more flattering than the other Bird styles.

I like this new style of Birkenstocks. I'm between a 9.5W and a 10W with a wide toe box (including a bunion). I could have worn the 39 for length but the 40 was a little more comfortable in the toe, for me.

I ordered a 39 (Womens 8-8.5) since I regularly wear an 8.5 or 9 in sandals, and was surprised to find these were easily a half-size too big if not more. They're cute shoes and seemed like they would have been comfortable had there not been a 3/4" gap behind my heel to the end of the shoe haha! Definitely size down if you're ordering these (sadly, mine are heading to the mailbox to be returned today)

I'm very glad I bought these! They are so comfortable and supportive. Exactly what I was looking for in a sandal. The only thing that would make it better would be to make it waterproof. I wear a 7 or 7.5 in most of my shoes so I ordered the 7/7.5 and when they arrived they were quite large so I returned them for a 6/6.5 which fit great even slightly big. These are perfect for running around all day with my kids!

Great! Exactly what I was looking for and stylish too. Note, the birkoflor is the synthetic upper. Time will tell how durable this is vs. leather. I do wish I got a leather pair instead, but I didn't like the hardware color combo with the black leather. Also, size down. I usually wear a 38 (7.5) in shoes like heels, flats, etc. For these, I opted to get the 37 (6-6.5). They fit perfectly.

I bought these for my 15 year old daughter. She has been wearing the Gizeh style for over 6 years now and decided it's time for a change! She loves them. Super comfortable right out of the box, cute, and can be dressed up or down. They are a true winner! She normally wears a size 8 women shoe and the 38 fit perfectly.

Love these!!

These took some breaking in but so worth it! I need arch support badly and these are wonderful!

The more I wear these sandals, the more I like them. There is definitely a break-in period. The edge of the footbed was initially rubbing the bunion raw on my right foot. I just kept wearing the sandals with a bandaid, and after a few days it was no longer a problem without the bandaid. Now, I feel like I could walk for miles in these shoes! I typically wear a size 8-8.5, and I sized down to size 38 regular after reading reviews. I initially thought they might be too small because my longest toe would occasionally lightly touch the edge of the footbed, but after breaking them in I don't notice this anymore. I tried a pair of 39 regulars initially, but the straps, on the tightest adjustment, were too loose. A 39 may have worked if I had bought them in narrow as I didn't really think the length was off by much, if any.

These sandals are super cute and I get a ton of compliments on them! I was concerned about the leather around the toe but it's comfortable and not a single issue with it. I tried the narrow width at first but I prefer how the wider fit flatters my feet/ankles. I have a pair of Birkenstocks from 20 years ago (still great!) and this new softer footbed is much nicer and easier to break in. Highly recommend this really cute style!

I am so happy that I bought these. I have chronic plantar fasciitis, and it's difficult for me to find shoes that I can wear for long periods of time. Birkenstocks fit the bill. The arch support is great, and they are really comfy. Being a teacher, I'm on my feet for hours at a time, and after a long day of wearing these sandals, my feet aren't hurting much. The toffee color goes with everything; it really is a good neutral! I love the little bit of a shimmer that they have. The only concern I have is getting the foot bed wet. I don't think that's a good idea, because it is suede. When my kids were throwing water balloons at me the other day, all I could think about was my sandals getting wet! So I took them off, and all was well.

I absolutely love these shoes. Like any Birkenstock, they take some breaking in. But I would wear them every day if I could.

I have flat feet, the arch feels almost too much for me. BUT that being said when I wear them often the other pains in my feet lessen. I am trying to acclimate my feet to the arch because I feel it would be beneficial. I purchased the regular width, and they fit my wider foot fine. They are made well, look good, and I hope I can learn to wear them everywhere.

These are so cute! The breaking in process has made my feet sore, but I know once they are fully broken in, they'll be amazing!

Love, love, love these shoes. I got the black oiled leather. They only took me about 5 days or so to break them in, and now they're all I wear! The leather will turn your foot black for a week or so, but that stops. Fantastic shoe!!

Took me a while to decide between this an the 40 and I'm keeping the 39 in the golden brown color. I'm an 8.5 narrow and the Mayari narrows fit really well width-wise. Length wise, my ideal Birk size would be between 39 and 40. In these, the 39 is a glove fit whereas the 40 is a bit big (just a little bit). If I came across a 40 at a great price, in a color I want, it would work. I love these so much I would like to have other colors, however, the narrow seems to be available only in the golden brown (very nice) and silver.

I bought these with the intention of wearing them occasionally for a little pop of metallic.... I wear them at least 4 times a week! They're typical Birkies, so super comfortable, but the style is super cute! They go with anything from jeans to skirts! I love them!!

LOVE these! I'm normally a 5.6-6 in women's and I ordered the 36 in the narrow width. Surprisingly, Sz 35 probably would have been a better fit in the narrow width, but the 36 felt fine and fit well enough to keep. I love the golden brown color and chose these over the gizeh style because the thong in between the toes bothered me on that one but this style was much more comfortable. These will be the only sandals I wear all year!

I love this Birkenstock style. I have owned the Arizona style in the past, but I like the thinner straps on the Mayari. They can go with shorts or casual skirts and dresses. They are super comfortable right out of the box.