Customer Reviews Birkenstock Madrid Big Buckle High Shine

I love the style, but I had to size down (a whole size). It isn't super comfortable so I am wearing around the house with socks to break in.

These are so good-looking! Love the big buckle in a soft brushed gold. BUT, they didn't feel secure enough on my foot. I wear Gizeh's and Arizona's non-stop but these flip-flopped too much for me. Hoping for a style next spring with the big buckle in brushed gold against black nubuck.

Super cute, slim birk option! And who doesn't love the big buckle and pink suede? Unfortunately, the edges of the suede were way too rough and just with trying them on, the rough edges hurt my feet. So, sadly, they went back.

These are really cute but in order to make them fit I had to adjust the strap to the last hole to make them narrow enough. I don’t have narrow feet so if you do, these may be too wide.

I wish I could have kept these, they are such an easy style that can be dressed up or dressed down. Ultimately, the big buckle was uncomfortable and pushed into the top of my foot when I walked. Had to return.

I loved the way this style LOOKED!!! I really wanted t o keep them. But they felt a bit slippery and loose and I was afraid I would walk out of them. I have a small foot . I walk a lot. I decided to return these. I think they might have fit better had the insole not been the slicker smoother leather rather than the traditional sueded footbed that I have always had with Birkenstock. Too bad. I wanted to keep them. But I did not.

I really wanted to keep these. A Great Style and a "cool" look. BUT. The footbed is slippery on my rather small foot. (5 l/2). I am returning because I think my foot slips around too much while wearing. I wish they had the original Birkenstock sueded leather footbed. They have a better "grip". I think.

I have several pairs of Birkenstocks and these were just a smidge smaller than the 38s I normally wear. I really like the look of these and was so hoping they would be like my other Birks. But with the single strap on the top and trying them out around the house, I don't think they are as supportive as what I'm use to with my other Birks.

Great shoe, ESP on $ale! I love the pink color---been wearing in the house, since I do not want to get dirty.

Ordered the Madrid Big Buckle in orchid, beautiful color and great deal on sale; however, don't think they will be comfortable for me since my foot is thin feels like this style will hurt top of my foot, tried on in house only for a short while and had marks on top of foot. Always wear size 37 narrow and normal shoe size is a 7 med which is what I ordered. Really wanted to love these shoes, may work better for someone with a wider/fatter foot. Normally if a shoe is not comfortable right out of the box I will not be able to use them, hate wasting money.

Very cute shoes! The footbed wasn’t the “normal” Birkenstock cork. It almost seemed like plastic. They seemed to run about a half size smaller than my other birks. The top of the shoe dug uncomfortably into the top of my foot with each step. Unfortunately, these were a return for me.

I own a few pairs of the Arizona birkenstocks. I love the look of this Madrid sandal and it was true to size. However, I had an issue with the size of the buckle. Because the buckle is larger on this style, with each step, it dug into the top of my foot and was uncomfortable. Sadly, I had to return.

I love the look of these shoes. One big drawback is they are stiff and will probably need a lot of breaking in.

I loved this style and they looked beautiful on. I felt pressure on the top of my foot when walking and that may be due to the stiffer patent leather, but I was looking for a dressy look. Exchanging for regular black leather and I’ll give them a try. I am hopeful!

I loved these shoes, but ended up returning them because the buckle is heavy and puts pressure on the top of your foot making the shoe uncomfortable.

Didn't love the style in person.

Love these sandals, but they could use a little more cushion in the heel.

I was debating since last year if these were worth the price. They are certainly cute. Better looking than the usual 2 straps style. I got the old fashion style 2 years ago in softbed narrow. Wish they would start to make cute styles in “regular” and with the softbed. Although I thought it would take a long time to break them in, I must admit it happened in about 2 days. The problem is, the top strap is still digging into my foot. It’s somewhat thick and the big buckle doesn’t help with flexibility. The positive note is, my footbed is nubuck. I think only a couple of colors are nubuck, the one specifically called nubuck. The others are plastic!

Like the shoe overall. But had to return for a smaller size. I usually wear a 7.5 so I ordered the 38s but they were much too big, my foot was sliding around on them.

I hoped these worked out. I brought selected the narrow and it felt fine. My toes are boney and somewhat narrow, there isn't any support at the foot so my feet looked weird spread apart.

These only came in narrow and they didn’t work for me the style was beautiful though . I am worried about one strap and not feeling too secure on my foot , but I’m going to try to order them in a medium wide from the birk site . Wish Zappos had it available:(

I wanted a different style of Birks, so I ordered these. They are so cute and a bit more streamlined. However, because I have a bunion (ick) it just rubbed my foot in the wrong place. Exchanged for the same gorgeous cornflower blue in the classic design. WHICH I LOVE!

Very stylish, wear with skirts, shorts, jeans.

A little smaller than the same shoe in a different color. Slick floor but I love the shoe, they are so cute and I am hoping to break them in to feel more natural on my foot.

These are beautiful shoes. Love the style. The patent leather, however, seemed to stiff to be comfortable. Will get the black in regular leather instead.