Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Amherst Knit U-Throat

I like the style of the shoe very Much However, the shoe is Very difficult to keep clean.

uncomfortable on my right foot.

The fabric on the top of the shoe cut into my foot. This would have caused unwanted blisters. Too bad, because I really like the show otherwise.

The bottom part does not gel with leather top. Look very cheap. Returned them.

These are really nice looking and comfortable when new. They stay comfortable but the spongy rubber bottom is painted blue half way down and it just rubs right off. I can't believe a company of this caliber released a shoe of this quality to their customers. I may never buy another J&M shoe again

The eye lit where the shoe string goes through, broke. Wore the shoes 3 times and I can't wear them anymore. Bad design for the shoe string but comfortable for 3 times wearing them.

Had a good experience with another color so bought a second in black. While tightening and tying the laces for just the second wear, the eyelit came unglued and tore out. I really like a few of my Johnston & Murphy's, but this is the third pair out of my last seven which broke or tore within a few wears, so unfortunately will find it difficult to invest in any more pairs.

loved the shoe, BUT could not get it in a B width

Shoe fits well, looks good and is very comfortable. My issue is one of the cloth lace eyelets ripped out of the right shoe after maybe wearing them 10 times. Need to rethink that design.

The shoes look great but they don't feel great. We had high expectations from a brand of Johnston Murphy where quality and comfort are of utmost importance. We returned and hope that we get a full refund.

Didn't like how the felt or looked

I have had 4 pairs of these in different colors. The shoes with the painted soles do not hold up and they should never have been made this way. Painted foam is cheap and doesn't last. Already have a scratch after wearing 1 time.

This shoes are horrible if you encounter any kind of moisture on the ground. The soles have vents between the heel and arch. If you step in least amount of moisture on the ground, they suck it up into the shoe like a sponge. Then you are stuck walking around with wet socks.

The seam on the inside of the shoes were very uncomfortable

For me the shoes seem like they're poorly designed. The leather heal support is so rigid, and the insole is too thick, my foot did not fit inside the heel support section, and the hard leather piece rubbed the back of my ankle severely. I was surprised by this and a 10.5 and 10 both felt the same. The most uncomfortable shoe i've ever worn. I did return them in store and found another pair, similar in style that I LOVE. I think it was the CX4 or something like that. My new favorite pair of shoes.

Shoe didn't stay on my heel. It was almost like the heel area of the shoe wasn't deep enough to lock in the heel.

I bought a pair of these on Johnston Murphy website. One of the shoelace loops broke not even 9 months after I bought it. I own two other pairs of Johnston Murphy shoes and this is putting a sour taste in my mouth.