Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Amherst Knit U-Throat

The quality was extremely underwhelming. I've exclusively worn JM's for the last 6 years and these were disappointing. Sad to see the price keeps increasing and the quality keeps decreasing.

Color did not work for me. Returned and bought another brand.

after a few weeks of wear, the black trim is peeling off, can't really wear them anymore to work,

Not quite as nice looking as similar shoes from other manufacturers.

I think the shoe itself is very comfortable and breathable. I have the blue full grain and the light blue trim peels off after limited use. I love the shoe, but the appearance makes it unwearable after a few times wearing it. I own many JM shoes that I love. I have the tan and they are great since they don't have any color trim.

I would have preferred that the sole be white instead of gray.

Shoelaces too short Seems narrow for a medium width

Not quite the support of the prentiss my favorite.

the sneaker isn't cut high enough in the back it keeps pulling off the back of my heel when I walk which started to irritate the back of my heel above my ankle

I feel like I'm walking out of the back of the shoes when I wear them.

great looking shoe. just runs small with a small toe box. but i will keep them.

Too bulky

Great looking shoe but needs wider toe box.

I had to return the shoes since one shoe felt very loose compared to the other despite being the correct size. Must have been a manufacturing defect.

Bought these because of the great reviews about comfort, but was disappointed. The sole and ventilation are nice, but the laces are too short and make it tight around the top of your foot. I tested them out around my house and after just 5-10 minutes of wearing them the tops of my feet were red. I wouldn't consider the arch of my foot to be beyond average height. I'll be returning these to pick out something different.

Loved these shoes, not sure if I got a dud but I've probably worn them a total of 10 times over 1.5 years and the gray is peeling off, and the metal around the top lace got bent from tightening the shoe. I don't like to hear them anymore because they look so worn when only used a handful of times. My 3 other pairs of JMs have a lot better quality

Really like the look of this shoe! However, I ordered for my husband because we thought, based on the photo, that it was a slip-on shoe. However, it is not - it ties. He will most likely want to return.

The shopping experience was fine. The shoes are sized correctly. Unfortunately they are uncomfortable.

Sizes run large shoe did not fit. Returned have not received a replacement as yet

Returned item because color a bit to much for me in comparison to website photo

Not enough support

Looks good, the fit is good, the only problem is when flexed as I walk, the crease over the toes is quite pronounced. I will keep them, but I need to wear a heavy sock to make them comfortable. Correct this issue and the shoe would get five stars

I was expecting more comfort

Fit is true for me. Not the most comfortable if your feet pronate. Hardly any support.

Loved the shoes but the size was way off. I have several JM shoes and I'm a 9.5 in all of them so i ordered a 9.5 in this shoe and it's like 2 sizes too big, very strange.