Customer Reviews TOMS Cara

I really love the look and comfort of these shoes, but my heel slips out. I’ll have to return them.

Too small and needed to return for 1/2 sz larger.

Unfortunately slipped in heel and slight uncomfortable

Nice and well made loafer but my heel slipped a little. Not sure about them. Tried with and without socks.

The width could be a little wider.

They were nice, just snug

I bought two pairs of these shoes because I like the style so much. While I know that my feet are not the exact same size,(like most of us) I can usually fix it with a heel pad. Still, with both pairs one shoe feels slightly bigger than the other, one pair it’s the left the other pair, the right shoe. I will continue to try and adjust because otherwise, they are comfortable..

Loved these shoes and was so excited to see they are available in wide; unfortunately they seem to run long because they slip off my heels.

Cute loafers. Wanted to like and keep, but they were narrow and despite wearing them around inside, they didn't seem to stretch out.

I love this shoe but it is too loose in the heel. I ordered a 9 and my heel slipped but my toe was at the top. I sent it back for a 9 1/2 and it fit well but again my heel slipped out. I love them but they have to go back.

My feet are just a bit wider than C or medium width. Because of this, these are not the right shoes for me. I am very impressed with how far TOMS has come. These are so much more comfortable than the original slip-ons. Now that I've aged along with the TOMS brand, I can no longer wear the old classics because my feet need more support. These loafers are really great looking and would be so comfortable outside of the width. They are too tight in the toe box and my little and big toes are too rubbed on the sides. I'm sure these would break in, but I no longer put myself through the effort. I ordered another loafer from KorkEase and I'm going with those. These TOMS are sadly returned, but I would try the brand again in a different style. With the almond toe box and band across the instep, these are just not for feet that are a bit wide. Thanks for fast and easy returns, Zappos!

Definitely order up at least half a size - I ordered half a size larger and feel like I could maybe even go up a whole size. Very stylish shoe - goes with so many different outfits.

Tighter than expected even with going up 1/2 a size. I am a true 8-1/2 and like to go up to a 9 in loafers. These are tighter than I was hoping for. Very cute though! Comfy once broken in which took a few days. Recommend, would suggest going up a whole size if you aren’t looking for a tighter fit.

I am a size 9 in all other brands of shoes. I have worn a lot of Toms. In their ballet flats I wear an 8.5. In all other Toms I am solidly a 9. Not in these. I could barely get my foot into a 9. They are very narrow. I ordered a 9.5 and though they fit better, I am still undecided as if they are going to be wearable. They are very tight.