Customer Reviews L.L.Bean Bucksport Plain Toe Shoe

The shoes fit great - true to size. I think they are made well enough to last although too soon to tell at this time. The only downside in fit is the lack of depth at the heel. Either the insole is too thick or the shoe is made fairly shallow at the heel. I will see how this low-on-the-heel fit evolves as I wear these shoes over time.

Look great and very well constructed. They will need some breaking in, very stiff out of the box.

Good looking, well made shoe. Sock thickness matters. Only 4 stars because of the break-in period otherwise great shoe

Have purchased 3 pairs absolutely love the shoe. But the sole is made from foam material not rubber .So i have 3 pairs in great shape that have worn out soles . . Make the sole rubber and you will have a great shoe

I bought three pair in April of 2025 for work. They've been great for walking around on hard floors all day. Took a while for them to break in but no worse than a pair of good work boots. Only issue I have is with the laces/eyelets. The top eyelet on two pairs is shredding the laces that come with the shoes. Currently looking for a quality lace replacement.

Nice thick leather. Sturdy construction. Needs some breaking into before extended walking for comfort.

These run at least a size larger than indicated, I recommend you size down. The included LL Bean "True Comfort" insoles are extremely squishy to the point that my heels were moving excessively when walking causing a lot of discomfort. I've replaced the stock insoles with some common brand "Stability Support" insoles and they've made a HUGE improvement.

I have worn the shoes about 20 times and the laces are fraying. No reason for these laces to fray so quickly.

Nice rugged shoe. The fit at the heel however is a bit slippy on my feet. My heel slides around, and the hard edge above the heel promises some blisters as the shoe wears in. Suggest you wear heavier socks with this design. (I also wish the light leather strip weren't so bright in color, but that is part of the design and I knew that when I bought the shoe. It's frustrating that so many shoes have vivid colors, logos, etc. I like plain old black shoes.) Overall the shoe is good, but still not quite what I was hoping for.

I love my shoes in every manner, especially living in Buffalo, New York with the weather. We are heavy now. They provide me the opportunity to go out and not be concerned about getting my feet wet or even cold. My one issue of disappointment is that my right foot shoe is a little tighter in the toe area so that when I wear for any Moderate period of time, my big toe starts hurting. The next size up would be much too large I tried that. Otherwise they look wonderful. They feel adventure some and protective and I'm very pleased with the purchase. Keep making such good shoes for the future Anthony Del Nuovo

I like these shoes. You get a lot for your money, but they aren't without flaws. First the good. They are solid, comfortable, unobtrusive derby shoes that should go with a wide variety of clothes. Break in for me was minimal. These were comfortable out of the box. The outsole is probably part of that because it is very soft. This shoe also has a very thick, removable insole which adds a lot of cushion, too. Goodyear welted shoes from a reputable brand for $150 (or less, I paid $130) are hard to find. These have a rubber slip sole, which gives you the option of an affordable cemented outsole replacement while still maintain sole waterproofness. The leather upper is good, water resistant and should last a long time. These are the shoes that I wear everyday inside and out and I enjoy them. Not everything is perfect, which I expect from a goodyear welted shoe at this price. The laces are trash. Just get new ones right away. They will break soon, anyway. The goodyear welting is 360 degrees- nice. That stitch does not go all the way through the outsole. There is an additional stitch that goes through the outsole, but only for about 30 degrees at the toe. Not a big deal, but not something I have not seen before. The shoes run large - for me 1/2 size. The insoles are very cushiony, but for they are are too big for the shoes. They raise my foot too high, especially at the heel. I replaced them. Last, the soles are very soft. The same thing that makes them comfortable, makes them wear out quickly. I would definitely buy these again. There isn't anything nearly as good anywhere close to this price.

I bought these sturdy, good-looking shoes less than two months ago, and I am almost completely satisfied with these sturdy, good-looking shoes, including their attractive design, solid construction, and wear-resistant tread. However, my one disappointment are the shoe laces, which quickly began to fray, stretch, and break; in addition, Bean does not carry replacement laces (but will reimburse the documented purchase of new laces from another retailer).

The shoes were definitely worth the purchase they're comfortable sturdy and they would definitely buy them again

I was looking for a quality leather shoe with a leather midsole and Vibram lugged sole. The Bucksports hit the nail on the head. They are great looking shoes that should last forever, and could most likely be resoled if necessary. However...the insoles had strange raised areas at the heal and ball areas that made them feel strange to walk on. I replaced them with a pair of flat, gel insoles and the result was so much better comfort and a much better walking experience.

Shoe is good. Not as comfortable on longer walk as I hoped. But traction is great. Good look and waterproof so far

I've been wearing them for a couple of weeks in rainy Portland OR. They've taken over a my main pair of outdoor shoes.

Love the look and feel of them so far. Ask me in five years and I'll really be able to evaluate them!

Fit well. They were very stiff for the first week and a half but now are very comfortable.

I have ordered a pair every year They change toe sole to a foam from a runner sole . Leather looks great they completely wore out on the sole in 2 months .Favorite sumos but have 3 pair in closet i can't wear

not true to fit... had to return the first pair and order a smaller size

Comfortable, breath well, good for long days at work, laces only last a month. I wish they offered a smooth sole version, regardless it's the best work shoe, I've found.

I wear 8.5 in 2 major brands and other LL Bean shoes but I had to return these and exchange them for a 7.5. It has more cushioning in the mid-sole and in the heal compared with other shoes. While it was inconvenient to exchange they are comfortable shoes and seem to be made well.