Customer Reviews Marc Joseph New York Midtown Pumps

Loved the shoe but so very tight in the toes

Attractive shoe, but it dug into my heel and was a little too long on me.

These just didn't like my feet! I loved them but they were not a perfect for me. Well made, and stunning

This pump is so classy and my hope was for it to fit, as I wanted the style and color Marc Joseph offered. I did the recommended "go up a 1/2 size if you have a full foot" and even that didn't allow extra toe box room for comfort. The shoe looked great on but unfortunately with just a few steps on the carpet told me it was a no go. I wear a women's 9M and went to a 9.5M The width was perfect. If you don't have feet that swell and Roman toes, these shoes may work well for you. I really liked the color and style. Mahogony Burnished Nappa. Oh well, the search continues. As usual, Zappos makes returns so easy. Thank you, Zappos!

Beautiful in Cognac. Reasonable arch support for a pump. Needs to go back. But felt small and tight in the forefoot, even though I sized up by 1/2 for a wide foot.

too narrow in the toebed. I needed a wide.

Lovely color but too tight in toe box. Nice heel height.

Read the reviews!!!! I loved the style but didn't read the reviews. These were way too narrow. My feet hurt immediately when I tried them on, no way I could wear them. Too bad, the style was exactly what I was looking for.....I had to return them.

Too narrow but otherwise great!

So flimsy it felt like fabric rather than leather and extremely uncomfortable. I tried to make them work, which was a mistake, these were such a waste of money.

Very rigid and uncomfortable disappointed.

As others have mentioned. The run small. My toes were cramped.

I loved the color, the style, everything was perfect except for the fit. I normally wear size 7. I ordered 7 1/2 because of advice on reviews. Unfortunately my toes just didn’t fit in the very narrow space. I’m afraid if I order size 8 they might be too big on the heel. Big dilemma. I’m disappointed.

the color was rubbing off of the shoe. It was all scuffed. These are not true colored leather pumps.

Not a true 7.5 - fit more like a 7 and Zappos wouldn’t let me return despite their claimed 365 returns

STAY CLEAR OF THESE SALE SHOES! It says no returns on the website page, but there are also NO EXCHANGES if they don’t fit right.

Nice shoes, but the toe box is scanty and constrictive.

I wear an 8.5, but ordered a 9. It was way too small. Like size 7.5 or 8.

This is a beautiful shoe however, there is no way it is a size 10. I couldn't even get my foot into the shoe!

Toe part was super tight but rest of fit was fine

Absolutely gorgeous shoe in red. Very flattering on. It was just too small for me. Had to return. Next size wasn't available, but I did purchase the next size in navy,

This is not a Size 4.

Way too narrow. Made for a skinny boney foot.

Cute shoe. Would not stay on my skinny foot. Likely me but so so comfotable I would recommend but not for a skinny foot like mine

Everythings great except they are extremely noisy! Skeaking and scraping at every step