Customer Reviews Marc Joseph New York Midtown Pumps

fit was too narrow. the shoes are very nice looking. Just didn't fit.

I want a bit more room in the toe for a rounded shoe, but the rest of the shoe is very comfortable.

very nice quality, but the size was too small and I ordered half size larger than normal. too tight

Bought two by mistake

Very cute shoe but just too tight

Love the look. Had to exchange from a size 7 to a 7 1/2 run small.

The Midtown pump seems to run smaller in size than the NYC pump by Marc Joseph, comparing similar sizes. It runs a little tighter in the toe box and seems a little shorter in length. Externally the shoes seem to match in size, but it's the interior fit that's a bit different.

Beautiful shoe, it runs small.

Beautiful shoe, well made, love the color. The heal was a little too high for me, so unfortunately returning it.

Unfortunately had to return - I ordered 1/2 size up and they were still constricting. Toe box was just too narrow though the rest of the shoe felt fine width wise. Aside from the toe box felt like it would be great! Love the style.

Cute shoe for work, I would say it fits pretty close to true to size, it just pinched a little bit on my right foot by the big toe. I have a normal width foot. Ended up ordering a very similar looking shoe by Vionic that fit like a dream with buttery soft leather.

This is a beautiful shoe and the patent navy is subtle & elegant.

Beautiful shoes but not as comfortable.

I have two other pairs of Marc Joseph shoes in an 8.5 that fit perfectly but these were a bit short and snug around the toe area. I was disappointed to return as they are very pretty shoes with the perfect heel height and a nicely rounded toe.

These are so very pretty. They fit great and look so nice. Shoes to wear very often.

Beautiful shoes. I think shoes made in European countries should be labeled with European sizes. I wear size 7 -7 w in American shoes and 38 in European shoes. For instance Ecco shoes size 38.

The size and fit were his....it was the height of the heel that I couldn't wear. My back immediately started aching after about 2 minutes of standing, just trying them on. The heel is probably great for younger women, but for an older woman such as I am ... A bit too high and uncomfortable!

I bought this shoe in black and navy. The navy did not fit the same as the black. It was cut lower and was narrower across the front. I was disappointed to have to return the navy.

So very cute and the chunky heel makes it very easy to walk in. The shoe is a little small and tight in the toes. They are sold out of other size options so I will keep the size 13 M and make it work.

These run at least half a size to a whole size small. I made the mistake of trying to squeeze my foot in - and wow did i pay for it. These run very small.

These are nice shoes. The heel is about a 1/2 inch too high for me- I prefer a 2 1/4" heel height. These are closer to three. Perfect if you are looking for a higher block heel.

This is a pretty navy patent pump. I ordered a 7.5, which was too small. I normally wear a 7-7.5, so the sizing was off. Ordering a size 8 since I liked the look and feel of the pump.

They look better than feel. Leather is not soft, back will rub my feet. Color is very nice.

These pumps are very attractive, made of nice material. My perfect size is usually a 10.5 medium width which is what I bought. I've never tried this brand before. The arch is too short from the heel to the ball of my foot consequently the ball support is too short to keep the toes from hitting the front of the shoe. Perhaps a size 11 would be better but I'm concerned 11 would be too wide and gap when I walk.

It felt like a half size smaller than my usual size 9. I also noticed that the suede seemed worn off in spots