Customer Reviews Birkenstock Mayari Oiled Leather

I usually wear an 8 these are for 7-7 1/2 And they fit perfectly. Super comfortable shoes. This is my first pair of Birkenstock’s and I love them!! So cute!!!

I usually wear a size 8.5 or 9 in sandals and I went a half size down and so glad I did. I bought the 39 which is a size 8-8.5 they are perfect!

It took me two tries to find the right size. I wear an 8 in most shoes normally so I ordered the 39 in these shoes. They were way too big. Sent them back and ordered the 38 and they fit perfectly.

Takes a day or to to break in as they start molding to my feet. They feel great and love the slip on feature which makes them easy around the house or out and about. They are pretty so can go to church with a dress or dress down with anything. I wear Birkenstocks around the house also for support. I got the narrow as I am tall and feet are narrow so they fit great. Over time I can adjust the buckle if needed.

Very nice, but took a few days to make sure they were ok. I love the soles on these; they feel like they are massaging my feet when I'm resting/ just standing or sitting. . Very cute on!

Very pleased with the Birkenstock Mayari. Haven't owned a pair of Birkis in many years, drifted away from them, don't remember why, but decided to get another pair and am so pleased they haven't changed their comfort and style! Happily, no break-in period was needed, the arch support is super, and they look great with just about everything!

This is my 1st pair of Birkenstock's (I'm 50). I have flat, wide feet and a bunion. During the summer, I usually wear my Vionic flip flops. I decided to look for a summer sandal that would give more overall foot and ankle support for walking and travel. I believe the Mayari is going to be what I need. Felt great right out of box. I usually wear a 9 1/2 Wide. The size 40 fits perfectly. Although, when I tried on the Tobacco (leather straps vs Birko Flor), it was a looser fit and had to adjust the straps by a couple holes. Was looking for a color that wasn't too dark or too light and decided on the Stone color. It's just right and still a very neutral color.

This is my 3rd pair of Mayari. I love my Birks! I have extremely high arches and these are the most comfortable sandals for arch support for me. I spent 12 days walking around Paris recently and wore the same pair of Birks the whole trip, my feet never felt sore or tired. This new pair has been great, no break in period, can walk around feeling like I'm wearing my old pair. I like this style, it's light weight, the straps don't rub or pull on my skin and there isn't any 'flip flop' with each step. It's like being barefoot, but better! I usually wear a 7-71/2 US, but I get these in a 37.

Great. Very comfortable.

It took a bit to get the correct size, but it was well worth it! My feet are size 7.5, medium width, although I sometimes size up in athletic shoes and typically order a 39 with European sizing. Based on other reviews, I sized down (38) and ordered the narrow width. Those sandals *just* fit and were perhaps too small. I returned those and reordered a size 38 in the regular width -- perfect fit! It took a few days to break the sandals in, and now they are very comfortable.

super comfortable, look great on the foot. The oiled leather did leave some color on the foot at initial wearings, but it washed off easily

I wear an 8.5 and have a narrow foot. I ordered both the 39 and the 40 Mayari. The 39 is a smidge short (I have long toes!) but the 40 was too big all the way around. The toe strap on the 40 was way big. I kept the 39, even though I don't think the fit is quite perfect. It seems that the footbed contours fit my feet, but I wish they were just a bit longer to accommodate my toes. The narrow width is perfect. I'm still breaking them in, but so far so good! This is my first pair of Birks!

I have a Morton’s Neuroma. If I wear these 24/7 I am no longer in pain.

I love the style and the color of this sandal! Birkenstock's are definitely worth the cost, so comfortable and long lasting.

This is my second pair of Birkenstock - first pair I bought during pregnancy. They are comfortable, offer great support and are very light!

I wear a 7.5-8 woman’s. I ordered the 37(6-6.5) must be male/unisex sizing. They fit perfectly and feel great on my feet. Love these shoes!

Ok, well, these are the perfect shoes. So comfy and so good for my feet and the narrow width is perfection. Happy feet!!

My third pair of Mayari sandals over the last 18 years. They are so comfortable

I wear a 38 in the Arizona and ordered a 38 in the Mayari. But since this isn't a soft sole, I wanted to try a 39 because my toes were right at the side. Unfortunately Zappos was out of the 39N. Thanks again Zappos for letting me try.

This is my first time buying Birkenstock so was hesitant about how clunky they would look on my skinny, long feet. I also ordered the Gizeh style which did make my feet look even longer. This style is more flattering and I am keeping my fingers crossed that the toe loop does not come apart as some other reviewers wrote. I have narrow feet but I ordered the regular width and they fit fine.

I love my Gizehs so I wasn't sure how this style's strap over the foot and around the toe would feel. Not to worry, these are just as comfortable. The bronze color is highly versatile.

Usually wear a size 7. Ordered 38 and returned for 37. Still have room at the heel and in front of my toes. So comfortable. After wearing flat shoes for a week and then switching to my Birkenstock’s, my feet and legs never felt better.

Birkenstock sandals NEVER disappoint! I truly suffer when I try to wear something else.

I wear a 6.6 or 7 but for some reason I need a 36 for this brand which is marked as 5-5.5 in US sizes. I will order one size down if you are going by the chart.

My first pair of Birks, so I had a little trial and error figuring out my best size...I first tried the Gizeh in a 39 and a Mayari in 40. I'm usually a 9, but like my shoes with some room. The Gizeh seemed to fit better, and was very pretty, but I found the the toe bar to be too ouchy, so I moved on to the Mayari, which at first seemed comfortable, but maybe just a little too roomy? (they definitely looked too big) I almost kept them, but then decided to send both back and try the Mayari in a 39. (thank you, Zappos, for such great service!) Perfect fit! After a week of breaking in, (they feel hard at first, and the very contoured footbed takes getting used to, even with my high arches) they are SO comfortable and are now my FAVORITE sandals. Plus, I happen to think they're super cute. ;) I want more!