Customer Reviews Birkenstock Mayari Oiled Leather

Love these Birks! They are the second pair I have ever owned, the other was the Arizona. They fit wonderfully and look great. Also love the fast shipping from Zappos!

I love love love the Birkenstock Mayari style. I would buy all colors if I could! These are a great basic (I got a sandy grey color whose name is escaping me) and so comfortable. I don’t usually like thong type sandals that have a vertical piece between the toes. On this shoe, the toe wrap neither chafes nor is annoying, and is great for stabilizing the sandal on my foot. Also, the diagonal line makes these birds look less clumpy/wide than all the other ones I’ve owned. Not that I care, I wear them anyway but still, these are very flattering on my foot. I think they are the best sandals Birkenstock makes.

Just a great toe ring sandal for a C width foot. I normally wear a size 10 so the 41/10 fit perfectly. Many times the toe ring is tight or just doesn't fit really short toes. What a beautiful fit. My left hip has been hurting for a while, and this has helped to alleviate the pain. Also I love the suede innersole. My feet perspire in the summer and these are just so much more comfortable because my feet don't slip around. They did take some break in time for my right foot. The buckle hit the bottom of my little toe, but is getting better as the leather is softening up. The color Lilac is just gorgeous. It has been a while for me and Birkenstocks. Glad i made the switch back.

I love these sandals! They are super comfortable and look really nice on. My only caveat is that I they were are a little big. I am between a 7 & 7.5, ordered the 7-7.5 but they feel slightly big. Not a big deal though, I just tightened the straps. Would definitely buy again!

This is the second pair of this style shoes I purchased . I have wide feet and bone spur on the ball of my foot. I needed shoes with arch support to take off the pressure. These are stylish and I comfortable . I can finally walk with no pain!

Love Birkenstocks, period. I've always bought the Gizeh style, and decided to branch out and try the Mayari, love them as well. Be aware you will likely have to buy 2 sizes down from their "recommended" sizing. I usually wear US 7, which says I should wear Birkenstock 38, but 2 returns later the 36 fits perfect.

Bought these for my daughter. She loved the style and comfort. The perfect summer slip-on!

I’m in love with my Birkenstock’s! They fit perfectly, they look great and they feel sooo comfy on my feet!!!

The Birkenstock Mayari is the fourth pair of Birkenstocks I have purchased for myself. I get the regular width because of my wide forefoot, and it feels extremely comfortable. The adjustable straps allow for a good fit over my bunions, not possible in most other sandals. I think the Mayari look more feminine than both my Milano and Pisa styles. Birkenstocks aren't supposed to have the same snug fit around toes and heels as other shoes, so while I wish they made a 36.5, I have gotten used to the fit of a 37. All Birkenstocks require a bit of a footbed break in period, but once through the first few days, they feel like magic on my feet. I wish there was a bit more diversity in available leather colors, but that's such a minor point for me. I highly recommend these sandals.

Fit and feel exactly as you would expect.

I wear between a 6.5 and 7 but have a somewhat narrow foot. it took me several times ordering different styles and sizes, but was extremely happy with this style and the 7 narrow fit me perfectly. So thankful for Zappos and the ability to return so quickly and easily.

My adult daughters favorite shoe!

Great to find this soe in narrow. Wish there were more color choices in my size.

This my fifth pair of birks—I wear a size US 6, but the 36 is always perfect. My gizehs just bit the dust after 4 or so years of constant travel and wear, so it was time for something new. I ordered the oiled black in the Mayari, but Zappos shipped my the blue mistakenly—it’s a very dark navy blue, and I think I like it better than the black!

Very comfortable shoe. I wore them all day just out of the box. Very good support and looks good on.

Overall spot on

They fit perfect! My new go-to sandal!

I have recently had a problem with pain on the outside (5th metatarsal edge) of my foot, and as soon as I put these Birkenstock’s on, *poof* the pain was gone! Wow! I am so thrilled! I wore them two days in a row, lots of walking, no break in required... but then the lack of heel cushioning got to me, so, as much as I love them, I realize I will have to rotate with other, cushier shoes. (Hey, I am in my 70s... the fat pads in my heels have totally disappeared). Still, amazing comfort. As to size... I wear women’s 11-11.5, wide... or men’s 10-10.5 medium. I got these in Euro 43 (which claims to be women’s 12-12.5... I don’t think so!) and they are a perfect fit. A little space at the heel, but I think Euro 42 would have been too small. Really really love these! Not only comfortable, but pretty, too.

I size down when buying these. I'm an 8 but a 38/7 in Birkenstock. Love the style. Love that they're leather.

Really like these, very comfortable! Did take a bit of stretching on one toe but overall a shoe wardrobe staple!!!

Love these birks, super comfortable and sturdy. Will have them for years.

Felt comfy right out of the box. The break in period was not nearly as bad as I thought it would be. It was a bit confusing to determine the difference between Birko-flor and the other one (I forget now) but the Birko-flor is what I got and it is really comfy.

I have very narrow feet (AAAA) and this sandle fits perfectly. The buckles allows a fit I haven't found in other candles.

I almost didn't keep these because I have an issue with how Birkenstocks look so bulky! But when I started wearing these I couldn't stop at all. I have been having foot pain and needed a shoe with strong support. These shoes feel like a massage everytime I wear them. I can't explain it, but after I got used to the look I just can't even wear another shoe. They are worth the money, because I'd rather have one great shoe than two cheap shoes! I had an issue with the sizing though. I am a 7.5 and both the 37 and 38 fit me well. I couldn't decide. Ultimately I had a personal preference for more room (since in heat my feet tend to expand anyway) and kept the 38. I didn't like the feeling with the 37 that it fit just snug with no wiggle room, but that's personal preference. I also liked the stone color because it was a soft color, almost a mix between light brown and light green.

Love Birks! These are no exception. The color of the leather is nice and they are very comfortable. The fit is true to size and fit as expected. This is my fourth pair of Birks and counting!