Customer Reviews Birkenstock Mayari Oiled Leather

First pair of birks. Still breaking them in, my arches aren’t used to such support. I got the narrow and it was perfect.

These run big!

Nice look to the usual heavy Birkenstock. But for my flat feet they were too large.

So cute! The left shoe toe strap was tighter than the right shoe, so I’m sending them back to exchange for a new pair. I hope it works! Love Zappo’s easy shipping and return policy!

I typically wear a size 9 and these fit perfectly. The leather was too stiff and hurt between my toes.

I bought the 8-8.5 size for my 8.5W foot, but they were too small, JUST fit. I returned and ordered the 9-9.5 size, and while these fit my foot length better, they just weren't quite wide enough. Birks tend to run wide, but they aren't true wide width. My feet sort of spilled over on the outside middle of my foot which made the shoes annoying. Too bad they don't come in wides! I would have liked to own a pair of Birks!

These sandals were comfortable and I felt that they would be comfortable to wear for long periods of time, but the color didn't work for me. It made my foot look swollen, so back they went. But, I ordered a pair in a different color and am anxiously awaiting their arrival!

A little bit big, not enough to return though. I think sizing down would have made the straps tight. But I love them!!! Great color and softer straps than I imagined. No need to break em in

Arch support was awesome! Unfortunately, the 8-8.5 Regular size was too small for my 8.5W feet. I'm returning to try the 9-9.5 Regulars. Hoping they'll work!

I’m really bummed. I’m a true 8, but must be between Birk sizes. Ordered the 39 and I was sliding around in them no matter how tight I made them. They were too wide. The 38s have my big toe right up along the ridge so it’s really uncomfortable. I was hoping for something out of the box comfortable, so I have to return. Will try a different Birkenstock style.

This is my third pair of these sandals. The others are brown and black. I've waited a long time for them to come in white. When I saw these, I immediately purchased them. They are exactly what I expected, fit perfectly and look great. My only criticism is they are NOT WHITE. They are pale grey. This is disappointing, but no way am I not going to wear these shoes and enjoy them!

When I ordered the image showed the gold Birkenstock logo in the foot bed, which is what I have been able to get in the past. What I received had the black print logo in the foot bed. These shoes are not as comfortable as the original Birkenstocks that I have gotten in the past. They will take some time to break in. I don't know why the fit is different, but it is. They are OK, but not as the product has been in the past.

I’ve been breaking them in for a week now or two. It’s my first pair of birks. I’m told the more you wear them, the better they feel and mold to your feet. They are a bit stiff but not uncomfortable - no sores or rubbing. After reading reviews I bought bought a 37 instead of 38 (7.5) I would usually buy. At first I thought might be a little too small as my big toe is right at edge but a longtime Birkenstock’s wearer who is same size as me said they were perfect. I have a regular width (narrower but never buy narrows) and arch. I don’t particularly like flip flops/things but these feel secure. Going to St John for a week and these will be my everyday sandal to go with everything. One thing to mention- they are not white as advertised. They are very pale gray. I think they are nice neutral that will go with everything even though not what I was expecting. See pics below. You can see the real white bottom against the upper is more gray.

I really liked the style and support of these sandals, but the leather version was super stiff and painful in between my toes. I’m sure they would have softened up eventually, but I liked the Birkoflor option better because I could wear them straight out of the box without breaking them in.

These sandals are really cute, very comfortable, have support for my high arches. I like that they are narrow. They're my first pair of Birkenstocks. I wear them every day.

I don’t think these Birkenstock match up to the ones I purchase 5 years ago. I feel they don’t mat h up the same, ( better quality back then ) but anyhow I purchase them again because I still love the comfort for long walks with a nice supportive pair of sandal. Let’s see how these hold up compare to my old ones. Let you guys know after wearing them for awhile. ????????

I ordered a 43, the equivalent of 12-12.5, and there wasn't enough room for my toes--they hit the ridges at the front of the shoe. They were cute and comfortable, so I'm sad to have to return them.

Overall the shoe fit adequately. After trying it for awhile (hours) I knew the toe post was going to bother me. Unfortunately, boxed them up and returned them today. Back to the drawing board.

Birkenstock PLEASE produce more styles in 43 /12 AA sandals !!

This is my third pair of Mayari's and I had to return them because they were too narrow. When compared to my other pairs, they were 1/4" narrower, even though they are the same size/width. I will try another pair, though, because Mayari's are the most comfortable sandal I have ever worn!

I have a few pair of the Arizona style but I was looking to change it up a bit and thought these were so cute. Unfortunately the suggested narrow width was a tad too narrow for me and caused the sandal to dig into my foot. I’d Iike to give the standard width a try t see if they are a better fit for me. Aside from my for issues, I found these to be a beautiful, well made sandal.

I really wanted to buy these, but the strap that goes between the big and second toe just hurt too much. It cut deep between my toes, and I couldn't risk it not improving during a break-in period so I had to return them.

I haven’t worn Birkenstock’s in a long time, but they seem so have back in style so I bought a pair an anticipated to Mexico. First off.. they are actually pretty cute. And , as I already knew, very comfortable. I usually wear 8 1/2 - 9. Bought the size 40 first, had to exchange for 39. I’m loving them.... can’t beliv I waited so long to buy another pair. The buckle by the toe did rub at first, but relaxed after wearing for about 5 days... so comfy now. Definitely recommend!