Customer Reviews Birkenstock Mayari Oiled Leather

I initially ordered a 38, which was too long. I returned the 38s and ordered a pair of 37s. The length is better, but they are substantially narrower than the 38s. I had to double check and make sure I didn't accidentally order a narrow width. They are overall comfortable, but are too narrow for all day wear or long walks.

My first experience with Birkenstocks. I am regularly a size 6 in pretty much every shoe brand and type, and according to the size chart, I ordered a Birkenstocks size 37. It was way too large -- while it was OK width-wise, the space behind the heel was at least 1" extra. Returned for the same style but Birkenstocks size 36. This fits perfectly, with just enough space behind the heel, and while the whole shoe is stiff starting out, I'm liking the support. The upper is Birko-Flor and very comfortable.

love the look of the shoe but unfortunately it did not fit. It was too big.

When you sent me a replace pair that did not have a problem with a toe loop, everything fit well and I am very happy with my purchase. Your customer service was very helpful.

true to size, fits well for narrower feet at the regular width. Feel less bulky than the regular style; the footbed molds as is should but is a bit hard on the feet, could be softer.

I was reluctant to buy Birkenstock’s but my podiatrist said they are the only shoes she wears. So I decided to give them a try! they are so much more comfortable than I realized. they fit my foot like a glove! I was shocked! I love these shoes!

Cute shoes and I love Birkenstock but the arch didn't fit me so regrettably, I must return them

To narrow for a regular width.

I keep hoping that one of the brightly colored sandals will fit. They are always too wide. I own about 40 pairs of Birkenstocks but I seem to always get the “out of stock” message on a colorful pair. I love my Birks and wear them almost exclusively. They support my feet in a way that keeps my body in alignment and keeps my back from hurting.

I love these sandals EXCEPT that the tobacco brown looks nothing like the website pictures. And I looked on other sites to compare color...knowing that this is leather and there might be some discrepancy in color. Unfortunately the tobacco brown "looks like I stepped in dirt" as my kids put it. Very blah, almost wondered if I received the wrong item at first. None of the warm tan tones I expected, and I have owned other Birks in tobacco that arrived in a warm tan color. I actually just compared the sandals to a paper bag and a piece of cardboard. They should be called "cardboard," ha! Aside from color, the fit is lovely. Incredible arch support and the toe loop is very soft. In "winter" (i.e. with socks) Birks I am always a 38 regular. I have high arches and wear a 38 regular in almost all other shoe brands. However for "summer" Birks (no socks, more delicate styles) I always wear 37. Unfortunately due to the meh color I will be returning these. If you're looking for a very, very neutral tone and still aren't sure: grab a piece of cardboard to help you decide. Sigh!

I ordered a 40, which is the size I am in all my other shoes (US 9), and these are a bit longer than I was expecting. However- because they’re sandals it’s a benefit because I never have to worry about my toes or heel being over the edge. They feel very sturdy so far and the “leather” is breaking in nicely. They were quite stiff the first few times I wore them. I got these to wear for after I run, and they help my feet recover much more quickly- and they look good too.

I love the classic birkenstock footbed, which is wide enough for my c width feet. I also really like the silver color, alas the upper strap is placed far too far back and rubs my front of ankle raw. I am honest considering asking my local shoe repair uf they could move the startup up an inch.

This is my second pair of Birkenstock Mayari. I like this Birkenstock style best, because it looks less bulky. They're very comfortable.

I decided to return these. If I could keep them on looks alone, I definitely would. The style is classic with a definite femme touch. I ordered Tobacco leather, which is gorgeous, by the way. But, it does not fit like other Birks I’ve had. It’s very close, but not close enough. This style feels smaller and more narrow. If you have any issues with pain in your big toe, such as arthritis, the Mayari may not be the Birk for you.

Love these (the lavender oiled Mayari) but were a whole size too big. I wear a 7-7.5 shoe (size 8 in sneakers) and the same size (38) in these is a whole size too big. I would have reordered but they were out of stock so I ordered a 37 from Amazon and they fit great with still a bit of room at both ends. Very comfortable - toe is fine.

the fuchsia color was really much more the color of rose pink rather than fuchsia. The soft foot bed is an improvement, great shoe. Took minimal break in time.

Great shoe. The Mephisto seems to fit my foot better. LOVED the big toe "holder" but the strange thing is that when my toes fit on the foot bed of the shoe there was too much ROOM in the back of the shoe! There was footbed left with no foot on it. I must be a size smaller than these. But I really liked them. I will go to a BIRK STORE nearby and check on my actual SIZE.

Very comfortable and durable.

My advice is size down. I’m a tried and true Birk lover. I always buy the same size (39) but a 39 in these were way too big. A 38 looks a little small but fits comfortably minus the toe piece. On the right sandal it’s very tight. I was sadly going to return them and then I tried taking the strap that goes under the toe piece and placing over the toe piece and that solved the problem. Bottom line: love them now. But some frustrations and work to get there.

Wow, these are super cute and the color is flattering on my skin. Problem is, the spot between the big toe and 2nd toe, rubs in a weird way. Maybe it's this material or maybe it's just the cut. I'm coming from a pair of Target knock-offs which were more comfortable, and no rubbing. I emailed Birkenstock, and they advised me to keep at it, wear them for a lengthy break-in period and use moleskin. For this much money? No thanks! I guess for now, I'll stick with the knock-offs. I'm super bummed. *See photo for uncomfortable rub point.

Shoes were as expected except for a defect - a glob of glue on the heel. So I immediately returned them; If I’m going to pay $125, I don’t expect anything but perfect. Not Zappos fault but should have been caught by quality control in my opinion.

The length seemed fine, my trouble was the width. I wear a 38 narrow in the Birkenstocks but I also have a pair with a regular width and I just tighten the buckle. The problem with the Mayari was the fit in the toe strap. It was extremely tight and there is no way to loosen that strap. Otherwise they were beautiful. I had to send them back and I probably will just order a different style.

Great quality, and SUPER comfy! I loved the sandal and it fit well, however my only concern was that it was super slippery while trying to walk. I was fearful of falling, so I had to return them. If Birkenstock recreates this sandal with fall resistant tread I would purchase them again. So sad I had to return.