Customer Reviews Allrounder by Mephisto Niro

The back of the shoe is too high. Hits my ankle bones, even with a shoe insert. Unfortunately had to return.

I ordered a 40 wide when the recommendation was 39.5; once i slipped in my insoles (not included here), the shoe fit perfectly with a good pair of walking socks. The "wide" size seems to run a little large. Not much in the way of arch support without the insoles, but with them, this is a great walking shoe. A little too casual for a skirt, but really nice walking shoe.

Wow these are ugly shoes. Online they looked okay but I took them out of the box and couldn’t get over the ugly factor. The fit was comfortable though. I’d try other Mephisto brand shoes just not keeping these.

Size 11 that I ordered was both too short and too wide! Too bad because it seemed like a nice shoe.

I wanted these to work soooo badly, but just too wide and I have a very normal medium width foot.

I like these shoes a great deal but the open mess is too abrasive on my feet so I am forced to return them. I will reorder with another style in this line.

I have another pair of these shoes without the mesh and they couldn't be more comfortable. This shoe has mesh the mesh is scratchy. This shoe would require socks. I had to return them because of that.

These run HUGE! I usually wear a 40.5 and I had to buy a 39!

Really wanted to love these but way too roomy and wide. I ordered a half size down- the length was fine but overall too wide and poor arch support. These go back, sadly.

Compared to my previous Mephisto this pair is smaller, almost a 9.5 in size. It should not be sold as sz.10. Color is nice, but hesitate to order another pair.

This is a well made shoe, however I had to return it because there was not enough support. I have bad feet and really need a shoe with good support.

Over engineered, under executed. The open mesh on the sides squished down.

I always wear a medium width. These shoes were so wide that my feet didn't even touch either side of the shoe. Returning.

Like all Mephisto shoes, this Mary Jane is extremely comfortable and good for walking, as well as errands around town. Unfortunately, the shoe looks very clunky. It comes up higher on the top of your foot than other Mary Janes and it's got a somewhat "orthopedic" vibe.

Not impressed, I am sorry to say. I have flat feet and I need arch support. I don't want to wear ugly shoes, but most comfy shoes just aren't very fashionable. For $165.00, I was hoping that the price would be worth it, with foot comfort. I've been wearing these around the house for 3 hours. My feet hurt. Sadly, I'm sending these back. Maybe for people who don't suffer from fallen arches, these are great shoes. They just aren't comfy enough for my needs, those they're cute shoes!

It's a very comfortable pair of shoes but i have to send it back because it is little short. The other downside about this pair is that it's chunky looking.

Frighteningly frumpy! I was pretty disappointed in both the look and the lack of comfort - they are on the way back, sadly.

I tried the size 8 and my toes touch the end of the shoe, the 8.5 is 1" too long for my foot and the front across my toes is loose and sloppy - can't believe that much difference in 1/2 size - really sad at the poor sizing and high price.

I read a lot of the reviews before purchasing these. I have high arches and plantar problems and hoping that these were going to be just as comfortable as my other Mephisto shoes. These were a big disappointment. These are not comfortable at all and there is no arch support. I will be returning them.

What other reviewers say about the heel of this shoe fitting strangely is true. I'm pretty easy to fit in shoes, but have never had a pair of shoes with such an odd/uncomfortable heel design. The shoe in the heel just does not come up high enough, hits at an odd place. And fits uncomfortably. These are super cute, just not designed well for fit.

Flat and very little support. Better than the Santana model. I thought these would have the support of a trainer and look nicer for Europe travel. They are clunky but not as bad as a running shoe. They are very flat, although, they appeared to have some lift to the heel. Orthotics do fit. In may case the shoe is too flexible and too flat. I do like that the heel can be loosened to lessen pressure on Achilles tendon.

I gave 3 stars overall because I couldn't wear them outside to give a true test. My normal size is 8.5 Medium width. I heeded reviewers' advice and ordered a 7.5. The 7.5 fit but my toes ever so slightly hit the end and undertops of the shoes. The only support I noticed was the cradling of the foot and perhaps that would help with overpronation. I wouldn't be able to fit in an orthotic with this sizing, so I'd have to order up a half size. They are lightweight and they are the type of sporty Mary Jane I'm looking for for a June trip to London, but they didn't make the cut. They felt comfortable for around-town errands and such, but I could never get away with these for a serious walking shoe without more trials of sizing, etc. I only gave one star for comfort because, again, I couldn't give them a true test because of the fit. This was my first look at Mephisto. And while I'll check them out further, I was surprised to see nothing special in this shoe.

I have three pairs of these that I've had (and worn) for a long time, and have just bought a fourth in the same size that I'm going to return. It doesn't fit as well as my others (seems shorter and narrower); while I'd like to try another pair in a half size larger, the site doesn't have one in the color I want. I did notice that, while my old ones were made in China, the new ones are from Thailand - maybe the lasts didn't travel well.