Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Lewis Plain Toe

Ordered 10.5 for my son . He has a wider foot and normally would be a 10 W but since this shoe is only M width , the extra half size was a perfect more comfortable fit . Color goes perfect with all shades of tan /brown pants . Worth the price . Great quality and durability.

Love these shoes. Great fit and very comfortable.

The reason why I return to Johnston and Murphy is because of the comfort and style the shoes offer. They are perfect for a long day at the office. Color was a little darker than I expected. Sizing was the same as other J&M shoes I've purchased in the past.

Great for casual

I've loved this brand for a long time and I had been wanting to get a new pair of shoes for a while. The website is good. The delivery is good, and the shoes are amazing. I get tons of compliments about them. Definitely will continue to buy from the website in the future

I ordered online and was sent a black pair instead of tan. I sent an email to support and within 4 days my tan shoes were at my doorsteps. I was told to ship the black shoes back within 30 days. I loved the tan shoes so much I am keeping the black ones! So comfortable!

Ordered these in tan. Very happy with appearance, quality, and comfort. These are my first JM shoes and won't be the last. Very happy customer.

I picked these up to replace my favorite pair of brown dress shoes and haven't looked back. For a size 12 with regular width, at first I was worried they might be too narrow at the toe but the leather on these broke in beautifully within the first three wears. These look great and are very comfortable to wear throughout the day. I appreciate the rubber soles on the toe heel of the shoe, although wood/cork soled shoes look great, inevitably you'll find yourself walking on polished concrete/granite floors at a hotel, country club, etc. and you'll be glad you're striding silently. When unpolished they are highly sensitive to water stains so you'll want to also pick up some matching shoe polish if you don't have some already. Overall a great product for its price point and a reliable brown dress shoe staple for anyone's wardrobe.

After a brief break-in period these shoes are very comfortable and widely wearable.

Shoes fit well and are very comfortable (I went down 1/2 size from my sneaker size).

Classic style, great comfort.

Love the fit, style, and look of this shoe. Great shoe for the price and very comfortable.

I saw them in a magazine. They looked nice so I thought I would try a pair. Very nice. Good price. Will buy some more.

I am extremely happy about my new oxfords. First, the color is gorgeous and it was easy to find a matching shoe polish. Second, they have a great fit although I tend to run small on shoes, these were easy to adjust. The leather feel is fantastic and JM are definitely masters of their craft at an affordable price for this quality.

Everything was on point from ordering to delivery. Fit was as expected as well. JM is my go to for all my work and dress fashion. Top notch all the way.

These shoes look great and they were very comfortable right out of the box.

The fit and appeareance meet my expectations.

Fit. Comfort. Quality. Everything I am looking for in a simple dress shoes. Highly recommend for anyone interested in understated style.

Excellent quality and the fit is perfect. However, there was what appeared as two spots of glue, on the leather, and would not come off with a cloth.

Quality and comfort. Felt broken in right out of box.

This is the Second pair of Johnson Murphy, and so comfortable!

2nd pair of Lewis plain toe. Have the brown as well. Good shoe and good value. Little annoyed by the slight crease in them straight from the manufacturer but wasn't going to send them back.

Quality shoe but it was too small...that was my fault. I enjoy all of my JM shoes. Wish they would have had a 10W.

Beautiful shoe.

Perfect fit and comfortable