Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Upton Wing Tip

I am an avid fan of J&M shoes. I have several pairs at all times and I already had these shoes in a caramel color, so since I love the fit and comfort of the ones I had, I bought them in black as well.

I wear a pair of Johnston Murphy's about 6 days a week. My foot size is a 13 wide and the Upton Wingtip are wider than I expected. Every step is very cushioned. The look is a little dressier than I was looking for but still happy with my purchase.

Shoes look great and very comfortable. You can dress up or dress down with these shoes. Look good with jeans.

Im on my feet at work all day and constantly walking around. I bought these shoes in late November and started wearing them in December, here I am January 29 complaining about them. Fits fine(10. 5 w), nice to work in, looks great. Why are the seams already going bad along the left wing tip stitching. Actually keeping them clean in upstate NY. Laces are good.

Comfortable. Curious how the leather will hold up. The welts of the 3 pairs I bought are not great as far as the joint. What I mean is that you can see some stitches that are not done cleanly and the line up or joining of the welt is not perfect. Again, J & M asks for top dollar but delivers lower quality. Not a great bang for you buck.

Great shoe very comfortable and looks great!

Like a lot of others, the stitching is coming apart and the soles are starting to wear through after less than a year. Rather disappointing they don't seem to be lasting long since they are a comfortable shoe.

Nice.

Cool.

Shoes look great and very comfortable. You can dress up or dress down with these shoes. Look good with jeans.

I'm a dress up guy, even in my jeans. These dressy shoes allow for comfort and class. I love them, and plan for other colors!

This is my second pair of Upton's, I have also been wearing a brown plain toe. It is an excellent shoe. The insole forms quite well to the foot after some use, and is very comfortable. I find that it does run true to size, but I buy a half size down and the leather stretches a bit over time to make the fit absolutely perfect. Just feels a little snug for the first few wears. The brogue is fairly minimal on the wing tips, but still very stylish, I have had several complements from coworkers. These are a great shoe for an office job where I am often at my desk all day, but am frequently on my feet for a few hours at a time as well. My only complaint of these shoes is regarding the first pair, the brown plain toe. The insole has completely come apart after less than a year of regular wear. I would expect a shoe in this price range to be able to handle a year of wear at 3-5 days a week, mostly seated. However, J&M has made very good on these, and offered a replacement shoe so I truly can't complain! These shoes have been my first and only experience with J&M, and it has been excellent. Great product, great customer service. I will be coming back for more!

My husband loved the shoe :heart:

Most comfortable dress shoe I've worn. They look great and shine well. I wear these and the black ones daily in a suit.

I've ever worn! I'll never go back to a classic dress shoe. These are not only comfortable, but look great as well.

It's typically very hard for me to find shoes that fit and feel good. If I do and they don't look good. This show however is excellent. It is very comfortable but looks really elegant. I love it.

Best shoes you could use customer for 25 years

Comfortable and looks good

Bought these to replace the pair that I just now wore out after 4 years. Great quality and value.

Excellent product.