Customer Reviews Cobb Hill Penfield Fisherman

These are cute and practical and should be comfy, but they didn't have enough heel for me. They should have been okay, but I felt like I was going downhill. I tried some heel pads but that didn't work, either. The insole was nice, so thank you for that. Always need insoles with cush and arch support, so don't ever quit with those. Cobb Hill might be the only shoe company who realizes how important these features are AND makes shoes in narrow widths!

I normally wear an 8.5 W or 9, but these were waaaay tooo long. Also narrow in the toe area for a Wide, and the heel slipped. Disappointing quality and texture to the shoe. Sending back.

Very comfortable shoe. Very attractive details in the back of the shoe. Absolutely love it. My go to shoe for everyday wear.

The only issue: the right shoe is just slightly bigger than the left. I am glad I ordered Wide. They are really comfortable and I like the color.

Very comfortable and the elastic on the stapes work well for my high arches. Love the dusty blue color too!

Cute but a little tight, even though I got a wide size I put a stretcher in the shoes and now they fit better.

I purchased this shoe on June 30, 2023, and it's too big. I've been trying to contact the company to obtain a return shipping label, but the company's phone message says the high call volume prevents them from answering. I've filled out the required form, but the company denies the reurn and doesn't provide a reason. I've contacted my credit card company.

Very comfortable for daylong wear. East to slip-on.

Finally I have found attractive comfortable shoes for my wide feet. I ordered my usual size, 9 wide, and they feet perfectly.

Great fit and love the elastic on the straps to allow for high arches.

I really like these shoes. I wanted a pair of spring/summer runaround slip-ons that were a bit more coverage than a sandal, but towed the line between casual and dressy so it would work with a wide variety of outfits. The dove color I chose is a gorgeous gray-beige and it works with so many colors, and the shoes themselves are very comfortable. The elastic makes for a good fit and my feet feel secure. There was a little bit of rubbing at first at the toes because I'm barefoot, but as I've worn them they've broken in even better. I've also gotten caught in light rain and they still look great. I have flat feet and Rockport is a favorite brand for support, these did not disappoint.

The shoe was well made and comfortable, however it was too big so I returned it The return process was easy and quick.

I ordered my usual size and the shoes fit fine and felt comfortable right out of the box. I've worn them all day on many different days over the summer, and they still fit fine and look great. Next, I'd appreciate it if y'all would make them in a brown leather for fall!

To me, the shoes are true to size.,I was concerned that I might have to return them, but I didn't have to.

I would order these shoes again. Good quality and fit.

Nice shoe but I should have ordered medium but it was not available. Donated them to a charity