Customer Reviews Cobb Hill Penfield Fisherman

Small sizes like Size 5.5 should also come Wide in size.

I wish these would have fit because they are very soft and supple. I ordered 7.5 in XW, and the width was perfect. But they were about 1/4" too long and my heel came out of them as I walked. A 1/2 size smaller may have fit length-wise, but probably would not be wide enough. I reluctantly returned them.

Insole is not removable so it doesn't take an orthotic. It was not returnable so I will keep them but can't wear them too long.

These are cute and pretty comfy, but I bought them for support and I think that's lacking.

I find this shoe runs a little wide and slips in the heel. I kept the shoes thinking that with socks in the winter, they should be okay.

I think these shoes are very cute. Width & Length is fine, but stitching on top inside of shoe rubs blisters. I wanted to return them, but with sale they are ineligible.

Good Point first - shoes are very supple for people who have problem toes. This shoe works very well if you have to have a support / orthotic to put in. Issue - Ladies with long toes need a half size larger. You do not provide a size 10.5. The 11 is way to wide for a slim foot. It fits as if it is on a medium foot. It is a half size to big. My mom's foot is a 10.5 slim. Please start making half sizes for those who are 10 with long toes. It is very frustrating trying to find 10.5 slims. My mom is 91 and so this shoe was light in weight. This was going to be her everyday shoe. Now I have to start looking again. Too Bad. Mom liked the shoe.

It fits well at 81/2Wide, but straps on the inside toe area gave me blisters on 3rd and 4th toes. Not good!

I have probably 7 or 8 pairs and wear and love them all. Some I have purchased on line and some retail. This is the first pair I have sent back. The back of the shoe did not cover my heel.

These are much larger than a size 7. (I bought another style of same brand size 7 at the same time that fits perfect!) Rockport would not replace with a smaller size and would not allow me to return. They are defective. They should not be selling on-line with no recourse for defective merchandise. If I had tried them on first I would have bought a smaller size.