Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Holden Plain Toe Oxford

Shoe looks really good with jeans or other casual attire. Sole has decent cushioning, but I find it to be pretty narrow. I don't have wide feet, but it feels pretty tight with a thicker sock. Also, for a more comfortable shoe, I would expect more cushioning at the heal. It is pretty thin and sharp like a dress shoewould have been 5 stars if it had better heal comfort.

Fits a little small but I think the leather might wear in a bit. I have used them quite a bit for work where I am pretty active and walking around, they seem to hold up well.

Great looking shoe. Could use more padding in the sole but overall great purchase. I ordered a 9.5W but it was too wide so I sent shoe back in the box it came in and received a 9.5R in just 6 days. Great response by Johnston & Murphy.

shoes must run a little small. Can you tell me how to exchange for size?

Pro: Looks professional Comfortable Con: Runs on the Narrow side in comparison to other shoes. Easily scuffs/scratches... shows every mark and requires constant attention.

Really comfortable shoe - softer than a sneaker. Smart looking. I found the shoes a little more narrow than other JM shoes of the same size.

The shoe is comfortable , but a little stiff at the ankle .

Comfortable width is perfect but a little long

The toe box is a bit smaller than I have experienced on your other shoes of the same size, pressing a bit on both my big toe nails.

Somewhat uncomfortable at the ankle but otherwise true to size and stylish

Quality shoe, great look. Fits well although they run a little large

Nice looking shoe. Very comfortable. I was looking for a little more casual style.

There were no options for wide sizes. Medium is tight but I alike the shoes.

Nice shoes, but ran small.

Shoe looks great and is comfortable to wear. I have wide feet and the W worked perfect. side at back end of the foot is a little high and stiff and rubs the ankle

They're good shoes but not great. The back rubs my heel. The frustrating part is my favorite shoes ever was a similar model shoe from JM that they apparently stopped making and this was the closest thing i could find and they're just not as good. Bummer!

This is my second pair of these shoes. To me, that says something. I love the way they look with jeans and the first pair lasted a long time. This pair has been a lot harder to break-in or I'd have give them five stars.

I love the casual style of the shoe, it's light, comfortable, and soft. I love the way they look with my sports apparel. NICE! Now the con it could be softer around the ankle. Other than that a nice casual shoe. Looking forward to purchasing more in different colors.

True fit. It could have a bit more substantial sole.

They are great, however the top of the heel takes a bit to break in.

Looks good, has a comfortable sole, but it runs small. I felt like it was pressing down on my big toe and so I probably need a size up. I returned it.

The shoes don't fit as comfortably as my others. The heel rubs and so an accommodation must be made to wear them. I think (hope) this will resolve itself with time. Styling is very nice and coordinates well.

I thought these would be more gray but are darker and have a hint of brown hue making a little off-gray. I still like the color and is not meant as a complaint. I've only worn them a few times but the back inside part rubs against my ankle a little but I'm hoping that will work itself out after breaking them in a little

Very good

Comfortable and stylish for Day to day work grind.