Customer Reviews L.L.Bean Scotch Plaid Shirt

Love this shirt, but quality is not quite as good as last year's purchase of a similar shirt.

Shirt is great with two exceptions - buttons are too far apart for women and the plaids are not matched under the arms like men's shirts are.

Fit, color, & pattern were as described and I like very much. The fabric is thin and not like other LLbean flannel shirts previously purchased. I'm concerned about how it will handle a wash & dry. Time will tell.

Beautiful shirt in the fit and awesome plaid design . . . . . Only one problem . . . . the tail in front and back curls up . . . so far ironing has not helped . . . .

This shirt is really nice! Quality is great, it's nice and warm, and I get a lot of compliments on it. The only reason I'm not giving 5 stars is I wish the sleeves were just a few inches longer. Maybe I just have super long arms, but especially for purchasing the tall size, I'd like a bit more length in the arms. It's not like the sleeves come halfway up my forearm so I wouldn't let that dissuade anyone from buying though!!

Does wrinkle, requires ironing especially the placket, Very soft and fits well

Wonderfully soft and warm fabric and great to see that LL Bean is offering shirts in Tall sizes (sleeves were a little too long). Also loved the colors (Washed Culloden) but alas they weren't as muted as they appeared online and the overall effect was too busy so I returned the shirt.

I'm 5'4", and 130lb, I ordered an XS this time, and it fits perfectly. However, it's a relaxed fit, which means a little bit boxy, I ordered a small size last time for another color, it's just too large, but still, nice quality, so I will keep both.

i love love love llbean's scotch plaid flannel fabric, but unfortunately this relaxed fit is unflattering on me. i'll wait until they come back with their slightly fitted cut and pick up more patterns!

Nice quality of flannel. Seems to be cut a bit too straight. I should have gotten a size larger so I could move more freely

I really like the feel of this soft, beautiful Scotch plaid flannel shirt. Medium regular fits me almost perfect except the sleeves are about 1 inch too long. I find this with all my Bean's long sleeve shirts. I'm 5'1'' tall.

a little boxy, I'd also like about an inch more in length but a beautiful shirt

Nice fit, very comfortable. I wear a long sleeve shirt under it as it is not very warm

I wear medium all the time in almost everything and this definitely runs large. I bought it for work outside in the winter so the extra room isn't horrible. If in doubt, order a small and medium and return whichever doesn't fit. I find that everything I buy from LLBean runs large.

Nice quality just too dark for me to appreciate the pattern

It runs small like all of the woman's clothing. Most times I can't wear it. It's a nice shirt though, so I'll keep it maybe I'll lose some weight and it will fit better.

I've washed and worn this shirt once and I'm back to see what other colors are in stock. Soft and cozy fabric. I ordered off the size chart and the fit is perfect. I wore it over the cotton knit shell with Double L mom jeans. Looked great.

Material was thicker than I expected. Very traditional looking and the collar was small so it seemed more feminine. No double chest pockets which also made it look more feminine. I purchased the red/black (cherry red) and the dark green/navy. Love the dark green/navy the most. The yellow pin stripe in the red plaid was not a classic look and would look so much better without it. Please make a red/white/navy plaid for women! Will not be putting this in the dryer! Tall size is barely longer! Would not ever the regular size only buy the tall if you are over 5'8".

Purchased as a gift by special request from 17 yo granddaughter. She wanted the turn down collar removed. I now has a mandarin style collar and is customized to her delight.

The sleeves are two inches too long for petite sizing. Otherwise the shirt is very nice.

I have worn these shirts for years and always rated them 5 stars. In the last 3 years the quality has suffered. The flannel is not as smooth as it once was, some are actually fuzzy, I like the loose fit but the shirt looked nicer with the button down collar which gave them more style. For this reason I give them a 4. They are still durable.

I own a couple of these (one in tall and one in regular) and the tall size doesn't fit markedly better than the regular. They're both too billowy (please, bring back slim fit flannels!) and their sleeves are too short. While I would wish for *slightly* taller sleeves on some of the few other items they offer in tall sizes, none of them, save this, are actually too short.

Great, crisp colors in this trending plaid shirt. Warm & comfy material. Size is a little iff; I am a small-boned, thin size 8 & ordered a medium. After a cold-water wash it is too small to wear a winter turtleneck underneath. If interested, it's made in Sri Lanka. The shirt is still a keeper. :)

Fits well, looks good. Hopefully it will wear well.

I am a 10 and ordered M (consistent with LL Bean sizing) and L just in case. Returned the M, kept the L for a less fitted and more relaxed fit. Soft, thick fabric and texture. More fashion than function with the one, non buttoned chest pocket compared to Pendelton. Black Watch plaid color scheme is very pleasing.