Customer Reviews Eastland 1955 Edition Sadie

I love these shoes! I bought them for nostalgic reasons, but they are so comfortable. The fit is perfect and the memory foam is wonderful. I wore my first pair of brown suede saddle oxfords for 20 years. The quality of these shoes lead me to believe I will get at least that many years out of this pair.

It’s not like they’re sneakers but they’re surprisingly comfortable for walking around (probably a mile’s worth of errands and my feet weren't sore) and they’re just cute. I like them.

I am a true 9.5 and they were a perfect fit. I don’t wear them with socks. These are a solid quality shoe

II am pleased with these shoes although the shoe strings are kind of thin and hard to keep tied. I would prefer standard shoe strings

This shoe is super comfortable and has become my everyday shoe. I wear it out, to the office and just bopping around. I get compliments wherever I go. Sadly I’ll put these up for the winter and am now scouting for a winter brogue-type shoe that fits as well as these. I bought my usual size and they work with a light sock.

I usually wear an 8 or 8.5, so first I ordered the 8.5. Too big. The 8 is just right. I wore them at home for a few days before introducing them to the outside world. They definitely were what I was looking for: sturdy yet very comfortable.

These have memory foam insoles and are so comfortable! Fit true to size. I get compliments every time I wear them!

These are my go-to school uniform shoes. I’ve purchased the cheaper ones and they are heavy, hot and don’t hold up. My girls wear these to death! I think my sophomore has been wearing hers for THREE years! I returned the 11 because it’s not much bigger than the 10 and too small.

I did get a half size larger and they fit perfect!! Love love love my new pair of saddle shoes!!

I have wide toes and this was too narrow to be comfortable.

The leather shoe is really nice and well made. I ordered a wide. The heel was too wide for me so I am returning them.

The fit was good when it comes to an average shoe, but I did have a couple of issues. Firstly, it has a very small toe box, which led my toes to feel a little cramped. Second, sometimes the shoe felt like it was wrapped around the side and bottom of my foot too tightly. Lastly, these shoes scuff pretty easily, but that is to be expected with white paint being on the toes. Other than those issues, which were relatively small, I loved these shoes! I wear them all the time, and they work for more psychical activities as well as a dress shoe! I get a lot of compliments from older folks when wearing them, and they fit perfectly into my 1940s style! I definitely plan on getting a new pair once my current ones wear out, but they have been going strong for 2 years!

The size was great but the heel did not go high enough. I felt I was walking out of the shoe. Wanted these so badly but had to return as a result of that issue.

i ordered a half-size larger as recommended in a review. Fit comfortably.

I first bought the 8.5. It’s way too long. Ordered the 8. Way too small. Not sure how 1/2 a size could be so dramatically different.

I got this in a size 11. I fall between size 10 and 11 depending on the model of shoe. I just got them in the mail yesterday and am still breaking the pair in. I can tell they will stretch and get softer. The style is so classic. I wish more companies made saddle shoes for women in more colors. As usual Zappos was great with shipping times.

I wanted to order these shoes, but they didn't come in either a 12 or a 13 and also XXX-Wide. Not all of us have child-sized feet!

I like these shoes, but they feel snug. Wide width should feel more roomy.

These shoes were well made and the sole and inside lining were very nice. Unfortunately, the heel was too wide for my foot so I walked right out of them.

Like the style and fit. Poor faux leather across the top.

I loved the look of this shoe, but it ran small. I have a narrow foot, so the width wasn't a problem, but it was also uncomfortably short. Disappointing.

Awkward fit and size. Needed to return twice for different sizes. Still didn't work out.

Did not contour to feet comfortably.

I've always loved the Saddle Shoe Oxford and wanted to really like the Eastland 1955 Edition Sadie. After reading the reviews, I took a chance and ordered a pair in 6M. The shoe fit very long on my foot and there was no way I could comfortably put my foot in the shoe because it was too narrow for my wide feet. The Memory foam insert isn't removable so I'm not sure if that would've made a difference. These will be going back.