Customer Reviews Naturalizer Bay Weatherproof Bootie

I am usually a size 6M and I sized up to a 6.5M which fit length wise just fine but I still found it a bit narrow with my thin socks on so it wasn't comfortable. The arch support was comfortable and leather is good quality but it's not sophisticated with my slacks/business attire but for those that like the casual look then it'll work great.

I wanted a pair of waterproof boots . Unfortunately the first pair that I ordered from a different manufacturer were running narrow. Other people also had the same problem. I finally decided to try a different manufacturer and they were perfect. Very comfortable

Despite ordering the wide shoes, these were still way too narrow around the toe box/widest part of the foot. Very uncomfortable. Returned.

I normally wear a size 7, but decided to size up to an 8 since I like having a bit more wiggle room, especially to wear thicker socks. The boots fits well, but I think a 7.5 would've been fine with regular socks. However, even with the 8, my toes felt a little more confined than I expected. Comfort is ok if you won't be on your feet for long periods of time, but I think adding an insole would help.

Very happy with these booties. A great way to still look professional and classy, while walking through a Midwest winter parking lot then around a manufacturing plant. Heel is a good height, and comfortable.

Excellent boots, very comfortable, I used them in the snow and they were perfect

The size I usually wear did fit but was a little snug in the toes due to the slight tapering, so I kept the 1/2 size larger. Very, very comfortable, and I've worn them for literally all-day travel. Once broken in, they fit like a glove. They are not overtly 'shiny' like many other waterproof boots, so these were the only ones that were waterproof but did not remind me of my grandma's rain booties. Of the three brands of waterproof boots I tried, these were hands-down the best fit and most comfortable. Plain no-frills style but that also makes them flexible.

Love these! Ordered several pair and these are my favourite. Already waterproof so no need to spray. Only detraction is a covered heel which will get damaged easily on cobblestone streets of Europe. Would have preferred a stacked or rubber heel.

Very comfortable to walk around the city in.

Naturalizer always comes through! The shoe fits great, even on my somewhat wider foot. The heel is manageable, even for a casual gal like me. Looks great for the office or off-hours. The price was a bit higher than I usually like to spend, but I think this shoe will last a long time.

these are great boots. Unfortunately the heel is too high for me, but they're really well made, soft, and comfortable.

These are great boots - unfortunately the heel is too high for me, but they are very well made and comfortable.

Comfortable and hold up in snowy wet conditions.

Very comfortable!