Customer Reviews Naturalizer Darry

These are very cute but were so tiny I could barely get them on my foot! I usually wear an 8-8.5 and had tried them in an 8.5.

Super cute & comfy once you find your size. I’m usually an 8.5-9. After reading the reviews, I ordered an 8.5. They were HUGE! I returned them & purchased an 8. Still slipped off my heel. I reordered in a size 7.5 & they fit perfectly.

The shoes look cute but the right shoe pinched my pinky toe and my heel slipped slightly out of the left shoe. I don't think going up a half-size would solve the problem, so returning to Zappos.

Completely agree with what other reviewers have said about the fit being off. I ordered the regular width and found it to be exceptionally narrow. I returned for the same size, but in wide. While the toe box was much more comfortable, my heel constantly slipped. I really liked the look and comfortable soles, but the fit makes these unwearable.

Too small, need to try the next size up

This shoe ran at least a half size larger than my usual size. Since it was so big I couldn't evaluate how comfortable it could have been.

These shoes are so cute! I love the way they look and they do run narrow which makes me happy! Unfortunately they were too short in length! I usually wear an 11 narrow so I am going to try the 12 narrow! I would size up on this one. If you have a medium or wide width they may be too narrow for you!

I ordered an 8.5W in both the black and toffee leather colors of the Darry shoe. I printed and used the size chart on the Naturalizer website to ensure I got the correct size. The toffee-colored shoes fit perfectly; the black shoes were way too small! I couldn’t even get my foot into the shoe! Same shoe, same marked size, but way different actual sizes!

Fell off my heel as I walked. That did not happen with 3 other pairs of loafers I was hoping would fit me!

Heel too wide, toe box narrow. Bought in wide from another vender but heel is huge. Bought is regular at Zappos but heel is still huge and toe box narrow. Love that it gives me a bit of height and would be comfortable if not for the wide heel.

Beautiful shoe but very narrow, I had to send them back.

There must be some serious quality control issue or just overall inconsistent sizing with this shoe. I usually wear a 6.5. I ordered the 6.5 and it was definitely about a half size too big. So I ordered a 6 and there is absolutely no way my foot will fit in this tiny tiny shoe. I guess this is why only 40% of reviewers said the shoe was true to size. You can't really win when sizing is this straight up inconsistent. I'm very very sad as these shoes are SO cute and seem comfortable. I just wanted them to fit.

I love the look of these shoes; the color and style were just what I was looking for, however, there are some quality issues. I tried the shoes on once and could already see that there would be rippling in the leather, along the side and bridge of the foot, if I wore them for an extended period of time. I also notice that the shoes "gapped" near the ankle when I walked. I have a wide foot and purchased these shoes in a 10W. They fit well in the length, but were a tad snug in the width and would probably need some breaking in - which would not be a "deal breaker" if it weren't for the other issues. Sadly, I returned them.

These shoes were size 8 1/2 but fit like size 9….