Customer Reviews Cobb Hill Penfield Ruch Boot

I thought these would be similar to an older pair of Cobb Hill ankle boots that I could wear all day and walk for a couple of miles with no issues. I've worn them for 6+ months and they have not broken in, they make my toes and feet ache even with orthotics. I think the toebox is too narrow and not high enough creating pressure as I walk. I compared them to my old pair and the width is the same but the toe box is straighter. The orange lining has also stained all my wool socks.

They seemed like they would be a win in multiple areas. It's difficult to find black boots with no heel that don't look like grandma style shoes. I can't wear anything with a heel. I was really disappointed in these for the price. My feet hurt a few minutes after walking, they give me blisters and hot spots near the toes because they run too narrow, and the orange lining rubbed off and stained multiple pairs of nice wool socks. I thought I could break them in but that hasn't happened. It's amazing that companies still can't figure out how to manufacturer products that consistently meet definitions for size and width.

Others have said these are very narrow, so I ordered XW. I have other boots from Rockport and Cobb Hill in regular width, but I thought, better safe than sorry. Sadly, the XW is still too narrow. The boots seem short, too, even though I ordered my regular size. If you are going to get these, size WAY up. I've been watching these for a year and I'm super disappointed. I am also unhappy about the restocking fee, since I consider this to be a sizing defect.

I received these for Christmas and have only worn them a couple of times. They are very cute but they kill my feet! I'm going to have to give them away. A shame because they weren't cheap.

these arrived today, they fit, they are cute, but horribly uncomfortable, no support, no real arch.

I wanted to adore these boots. Looks like I'll never get a pair that fits - between the time I ordered MY FIT (7.5 M) and their arrival, both colors have sold out. They are too small AND too narrow. I know the fit of my feet: I'm a ballet dancer. And these run small AND narrow. I sized UP for these based on reviews: half a size bigger and a medium rather than my usual regular (I have narrow feet). If even I have to get a full size bigger and a wide (!!), these are terribly fitting boots. Shame they sold out of them that fast. They're probably going to get a lot of returns from people like me who can't fit into their usual size, or even a size up from their usual.

Wanted to love these but still too narrow, even when ordered in wide width. Cobb Hill, PLEASE start either making your shoes in a rounded toe, fully wide style or make them in double widths. It's so disappointing to order shoes in wide sizes that are still narrow. I ordered them in the red and they are so nice but just unfortunately, too narrow.

The boots were good quality, but at least 2 sizes too big. It took me a week to get someone to email me a return label.

The most comfortable boots I have ever worn. Wear them everyday and my feet never hurt. They were like walking on a cloud from the moment I put them on. Would buy these again.