Customer Reviews Cobb Hill Penfield Ruch Boot

I wear a 9 N shoe and boot. Very hard to find a truly narrow shoe. These boots fit and were narrow enough in the heel. Very comfortable.

A nicely made boot, just did not feel comfortable on my right foot. I do a lot of walking and I felt it would be rubbing too much on the side of the big toe. Typically I wear a 8.5W and ordered that size and it was a good fit overall, other than the issue mentioned above. Had to return, unfortunately.

I should have ordered a M width, not W. I wanted to exchange them but correct size was not available.

The material was great but I couldn't get the boot on. If you have a high instep, this boot is not for you.

Love this boot however I wanted another color and red was ll they had in my size. I am returning it because of the color. I need a brown boot.

The arch support is woeful. The good news is the insole is removable and I could insert my own; but that pinched the toe box area rendering them a fail for a standing all day work shoe.

I was looking for a red boot and this is burgundy and doesn't go with anything I have. It fit well in the width but the top was scratching against my leg. They were very cute and I wish I could keep them.

I have a narrow heel and wide toes. This boot pinches my toes. I will be returning it.

Ordered size 8 wide, I'm usually an 8 -8.5, ordered the 8 since happily it comes in wide, need wide forefoot for painful bunions, these felt too long and not quite wide enough, and also not cushiony or supportive enough. Could not see myself doing much walking in these. Returning sadly because I love the style. The red color is great (not "muddy" as noted by someone else), it's a soft but bright deep rich garnet color.

I bought these in a normal and wide size. The regular felt way too tight, but only in the right shoe. Some of the problem could be how the tuck in the leather was stitched; it looked different in the right shoe than the left.

Love the style. Slips in the heel.

comfortable boot fit is a little big , not happy with style, seemed different on web site

The style very nice, detailed designs very nice looking bootie, however too soft for walking, not enough sole for bottom of foot.

Size fit okay,...very soft sole, not enough padding or sole for walking. the style is really nice and detailing outstanding, but too soft of a bootie for on feet most of day.

These are ADORABLE! Unfortunately for me I ordered my normal size OF 7.5 WW and they run VERY narrow. So they will be returned sadly.

These shoes are very cute, & *almost* fit my problem feet… a bit tight, but I think they would have relaxed enough after breaking in to be comfortable. HOWEVER, the ‘padding’, a separate piece, & stitching on the insole were very, very uncomfortable. Had to return them.

Fit was good. Very firm footbed, cushioning was minimal. Color is more maroon than red.

lacks cushioning and support, especially in the toe box. lack decent arch support. I will be returning. too bad since they are cute.

I have difficult feet with a wide front of foot and normal medium heel, ankle and calf circumference. For reference, size 6-2E Brooks running shoes with separately purchased arch supportive inserts fit depending on the style. The Cobb Hill Penfield Ruch Boot is cute and seems to be well made. I tried it in size 6-2E and 6.5-2E. Both were too narrow for my foot. The top opening of the boot was too big for me. My ankle and calf are not wide so the inside of the top of the boot could easily be seen including the size information on the inside. The slightly cushioned insole is glued down and is not removable. The arch support is negligible.

I have been searching far and wide for styles that fit my 7 1/2 WW feet. These came in "extra wide," but unfortunately they don't even feel regular wide! They're cute and would go great with a specific outfit I bought them for, but they are a bit smaller and MUCH narrower than expected.

I bought Extra Wide and it felt like a medium width shoe.