Customer Reviews Sofft Carleigh

Stylish and comfy!

I wanted to like them, but the color matched my skin tone so much that the shoe looked more like an extension of my leg than a shoe -- kind of like a hoof. The top of the shoe didn't conform to the shape of my foot, so it stood away in a straight line from my ankle to my toes, adding to that hoof look, at least on my feet. Maybe it'd be better on a wider foot than mine. I'd recommend getting a color that doesn't match your skin color. I did like the look, shape, stability, and comfort of the heel.

Super cute shoe. My issue with these shoes is that the back of the shoe digs into your leg/heel making it uncomfortable. I wish it had worked better for me.

This is a lovely open toed bootie. No surprise, the leather is soft and the comfortable. I am going to exchange this because there are too many scratch marks on the leather.

Cute shoes. Fit well, comfortable. Definitely lavender shade.

The only reason I didn’t keep these is that the prep toe cuts really close to the cuticle part of my toenail, causing a bit of discomfort as I move around in them. I can be a bit sensitive to that. Otherwise, they are gorgeous. The leather is soft and supple. The rounded block heel makes them look especially stylish. The heel is just high enough to look pretty but low enough to be comfortable. If only the peep toe didn’t hit in the wrong spot for me, I would keep them.

The leather is soft and the shape is attractive. I am returning though because this shoe runs a bit wide for my foot. The color is not the same as pictured, looks more apricot. So sorry this didn’t work as I have been debating for a while.

Good quality

Love the style of these sandals but they just didn’t fit me right. Felt a little big all over but the top of the sandal would have definitely rubbed the top of my foot. That seems like a very uncomfortable design. Sadly, I am returning.

Size was great, but the fabric rubbed against my toe on the right foot.

I love the shoes but the left one had been tried on so much that was entirely stretched out

This is an adorable shoe. Great style. Perfect size heal. I am typically a 6.5 in Sofft, and I was a 6.5 in this shoe as well. That said, the front lip that goes around the toes has a very tight, non-stretchy opening that just KILLS my feet when I walk (despite the fact that everything else feels fine, i.e., length, width, arch, etc.). I was incredibly saddened to send these back. Sofft - fix the front of the shoe! Soften that edge! It's too tight/thick! :(

These were too loose and pretty uncomfortable for me.

Fit and look was okay, but the top edge felt uncomfortably snug around my ankles (which are not large).

The back part of these were way too high in my heel, digging into my foot. Had to return. Cute shoe though. Nice heel height.

The quality of material and workmanship is great, as expected. However, the shoe does not fit my foot well so I will be returning it.

Wanted to love these, the fit, style, color and material (lavender brown nubuck) are fantastic! Unfortunately the toe cut-out and the part where the shoes hits the front of one's ankle are not well designed. They are cut in a way that the edge of the toe cut-out bumps against one's toes and the top cuts into one's ankles when walking (even though I have narrow ankles). I generally love this brand (Sofft) and have several other shoe-boots of similar ankle-height that do not cut into the ankle. If only this shoe were designed with the toe and ankle edges cut more in a small arc shape, to pull the edge slightly away from the toes at one end, and slightly away from the ankle at the other, instead of straight across! There is also an unnecessary finishing on these edges (plastic?) that would be better left as a raw nubuck edge, which would be softer.

Shoe ran narrow, making it difficult to put on. Very soft leather. just didn't work for me. Sent back.

Fit seemed a little small for 8 1/2. The 9 was too big and my foot slid too far forward when I walked but the 81/2 was too tight. One of them could have been sized incorrectly. I love the style of the shoe but will return due to fit and not wishing to fuss around with trying to find correct size

These shoes are very cute but the color isn't "coffee" as noted in the description It reads much more like iridescent purple over gray. Wasn't the color I was looking for so I returned them.

I was excited to receive these nice-looking, comfortable shoes (I wear a 7B)...until I walked in them. Sofft is a brand known for comfort so I had high hopes for these to be my transition shoes from Summer to Winter. They looked cute on, and because the footbed is so comfortable, they seemed perfect. THEN I wore them to dinner with friends. Within about 20 minutes of having them on, blisters formed on both sides of my right foot where the open toe is located. Disappointed to have to send them back.

Nice color, but they screwed it up with some sort of iridescent coating on top of the leather. Makes them look very cheap. Returning.

Very uncomfortable.

Size was okay however they were cut to high and rubbed the upper ankle in the front as the leather was too stiff and did not move when walking had to return

Cute shoes, but the peep hole irritated my toes.