Customer Reviews Nisolo Carmen Chelsea Boot

The quality is awesome! The sizing seems off though. Way too narrow and just overall too small. It's too bad, I Really wanted to like these boots. Also, some sizes did not come in half size.

I ordered a half size up and fit perfect. The boots are beautiful but for me too stiff and difficult to get on and OFF. They were just to expensive for me to keep and hope for a suitable break in.

I thought this was a beautiful boot, but wasn't for me fit or comfort-wise. For context, I have a wide forefoot and a high arch that push the top of my foot higher than average (sometimes called "high volume"). I purchased another brand to try them both and these were less comfortable, the top of the foot part of the boot wasn't high enough for me, the width felt fine (surprisingly), but I also didn't love the way that the heel cup structure seems like it was going to rub pretty badly, at least until I got used to them. I do appreciate the fair wages and environmental policies of this company, but compared to the other option (also $100 less), this wasn't the choice for me.

The shoe is reallly cute but definitely tight. I decided not to keep them because of the price and not being sure they would stretch to a point of being comfortable

Im usually a size 6 1/2 and not wide, but the 6 1/2 were too small. The 7 is better but still feels a little tight. Hoping they stretch a bit! I recommend going up a half size.

I wanted these to fit me SO BAD. I am normally a size 9 with a wide foot so I sized up to a 9.5. I wore them around the house to see if they would loosen up but they actually made the toes on my right foot go numb so I returned to try a size 10. Unfortunately the 10 was too big, even with thick socks so I had to return. Would love to try a different style soon!

I love the look of these boots and believe that when I break them in fully they will be perfectly comfortable. I have only been wearing them for about a week and can tell they arent broken in yet. They fit perfectly as I am a size 6 and they arent clunky or baggy at all. I feel these boots are an investment.

They seem like very nice boots, but I got the Brandy color and it was much lighter in person. Unfortunately, it was different enough that they're going back. The toe was more rounded than I was expecting too, which I didn't love the look of.

I love my boots. They are exactly the style and color I was looking for. Definitely size up a half size. The only reason I gave them 4 stars is they are kind of hard to break in. I have had them for a week and the left boot is still very stiff, but the right boot is perfectly broken in.

I'm typically a 8.5 -9. I ordered an 8.5 based on previous reviews and am glad I did. It does take some time to break these boots in. They're quite stiff. However, now that I've been wearing them a few weeks they've stretched a bit and fit really well. The almond color is absolutely gorgeous. Very pleased with my purchase.

I can tell I'll love these for a while. They are a bit narrow, but are loosening up with wear as some of the other reviews suggest. Sizing up didn't work for me - my heels were slipping. Great customer service as I ended up having to exchange.

These boots are stunning. I couldnt believe how pretty right out of the box. They are a little on the narrow side, hence me taking off one star. I have narrow feet anyway, so I dont usually have this problem with boots. But Im hopeful the leather will stretch as I wear. The sole is really comfortable.

I expected a break-in period based on some of the reviews but found the boots to be very comfortable out of the box. There's really good arch support and cushioning near the heelI especially appreciate this because other leather boots often chafe my heel. They're cute too though I wonder if they make my feet look a tad big? But overall, would recommend highly and am considering another Nisolo purchase soon.

These books are gorgeous; the only reason that I didn't give five stars is that I followed the advice of others and sized up. I am returning them, as they are too long. I ordered my regular size and have my fingers crossed that they'll work out!

These boots are BEAUTIFULthe stuff of dreamsand I'm so sad they didn't work out for me. I have abnormally narrow feet, ankles, and heels, and I was so hoping these would work for me since they run a bit narrow (I got my normal size 9). There was just too much room for my feet to slip around in, even when I put in inserts or wore thick socks (all while trying them on at home). I reached out to customer service and they suggested trying the Amalia boot since the laces allow for a snugger fit, so I'm hoping those work out better! But I'm still heartbroken over these boots.

These were gorgeous boots, but a little hard to pull on, so I exchanged them. Very well made.

These are beautiful boots that are casual yet refined. They are heavy, so if you are sensitive to that, look elsewhere, but they are so well made. The boots are a bit bulky and I am still breaking them in, so time will tell whether they earn their fifth star.

Ahhh, I really really *really* wanted to love these boots, but they just didn't work out for me. I ordered two sizes (depending on the brand, I can be either or) 7 1/2, and an 8. The size 8s were too long for my feet, and the 7 1/2s were too small. I feel like I could have made the 7 1/2s work but I wouldn't have been able to wear thick socks with them. I also have flat, wide-ish feet, so that may have been why they didn't fit as I wanted them to. Overall though, the design is beautiful, and I'm sure will look super cute on just about everyone else.

I love these! I had to order a size up from my normal size for some room for thicker socks. Love these so much but the tag on the heel that helps you get them on broke the first time I put them on. I sewed it back on myself, just wish that one little detail was better!

I could hardly get the boot on and then when I did the leather upper rubbed against my leg. I struggled to get them back off BUT they are a beautiful boot!

Beautiful and sturdy, but too tight around heel/hard to get off and the leather was already scratched, so not likely to hold up well.

I ordered down a half size and I could still only barely get these on.

They were too stiff and it was painful to walk

Ordered my normal 7.5 and I could barely get my foot inside. Also way too narrow (and I don't have wide feet). Order up a size... or two!

I loved the look of this boot, beautiful color and style, but it felt small for the size and the leather was stiff.