Customer Reviews L.L.Bean Wicked Good Slippers Squam Lake

So I absolutely loved these slippers but the sizing is very off and so I ended up returning both 9s and 8s and not ordering any more. I am usually a 8.5 -9 but the 8s were too big and by the time I paid for return shipping on both sets and lost my first order discount, it got so expensive that I ended up not ordering a 7 to try. I think I would be a 7 in these which means they run really large. I am only writing this review in case you are considering them. They are gorgeous slippers and super comfy and the cork sole is very cushiony. But order a size or 2 down.

Very comfortable but should have taken the advice of prior reviews. Usually wear a 9 or 9.5 but the size 9 are huge. Even with heavy socks the are still too big. Will reorder size 8.

The slipper is warm and comfortable but too large. I ordered the size 8 and it was too long, my heels were slipping out. Returned those and ordered a size 7 and the same problem. Returned them too. Too bad because they are very warm.

I ordered these slippers originally in a size 8 and they were too big for my size 7 1/2 foot so I returned them for a size 7. These were also too large, especially in the heel. I was always going to slip out of them. They're darling, warm and comfortable but unless you have a wide foot, you might try a different style.

Weird that these are too big as i have ordered the same size always

These slippers felt comfy and had no laces which is a plus. I just wish they had a regular heel. These are low profile heels that don't stay on my feet. I ordered the purple which was pretty but returned them. Please make these with full padded heels!

I wanted so much for the Wicked Good Slipper to work. Ordered them in the high slipper style. Much too large, especially in the heel. Fell off my feet. Returned them for the Squam Lake style. Much too large, slipped right off my feet. I will return these also but afraid to order the moccasin style. I ordered these in my usual size. Other older reviews said these run small; not for me. Different manufacturer?

Size 7 too small, size 8 too large Not an appropriate fit for me. The company is great for refunds etc.

I ordered a size 9. It's the size they said to order if I wear a 9 and 1/2. They came and they're huge. I called and was sent another pair size nines. The customer service person thought that mine were labeled incorrectly. The second pair came and they were the same huge size. If I wanted to order a third pair I would have had to have paid for them to get here. That means paying for two pair when both those pair are too big. So I returned the second pair and ask them to send me a size 8. They told me I could wear the original pair until I got a pair that fit me. They're way too huge and my feet slide around in them. The quality is fine. I'm just saying that the size 9 is huge.

I have a very narrow foot so the slipper was too wide. The slipper was well made but I couldn't keep it on my feet.

I think I might step out of these shoes. They feel good but are a bit wide.

Requested exchange but I have to wait more than 3 months (100 days) to be exact.

Good quality material but poor fit. Loose in heal even with proper sizing. Keeps slipping out.

I LOVE the Llbean slippers, but this style wasn't for me. While I wear a 10, these fit just fine, but the heels were much more exposed than they appeared in the picture. I like a more secure slipper and these felt like I was chasing them to get them to stay on. I'll stick to the ones with the laces.

The slippers were great, except the right one's fur on the outside begins and ends at the back and the left one begins and ends on the right side. There is a definite seam. It is a defect, but I am wearing them anyway, instead of sending them back.

Beware ... These slippers run very large. The slippers look very nice but I need to return them. I take a Women's size 7.5 or 8 shoe and an 8 boot. I ordered size 8 slipper but when I tried to wear them my foot came right out of the slipper. They are too big. I tried to return them to 2 LL Bean stores but they only had the brown color in the stores which I did not want. I will try to send them back but now I will have to pay a return fee,

These slippers appear well-made and comfortable. Unfortunately, the size was wrong. I wear a true size 8 and this slipper was huge on me. It was too wide and too long. I am exchanging it for a size 7 to see if it will fit. Stay tuned...

I wear all my shoes in a size 9, but my heal popped out of this shoe when I walked. A shame it does not come in half sizes or I would have just ordered another pair. Back they go

I'm a 6.5 and I'm bummed I followed the advice to order up to a 7, they are way too big and wide. Sending back and not bothering to order a smaller size.

They said if half size order up and they were too big. The sole is a plastic like material, stiff and slippery. Was very disappointed as they are not as they appear.

Beautiful, high quality product. I wanted something without laces, but these are going back. Sole is very stiff, like walking on a board. Not the soft, cozy feeling I want with a slipper. My shoe size is 7.5. Per the description, I sized up and they are too big.

The quality of the shoe is not what it used to be. I am vey and plan on returning them.

I wish I could love these slippers. They were just what I wanted. Well made and comfy. But they were way too big. I normally wear a 10.5 wide but ordered size 10 because I wanted them snug. They were more sized like a men's size 10 - huge. Too much of a hassle when I returned them so I won't take chances ordering an even smaller size.

I bought this same slipper about 2 years ago and loved it. This one I bought exact same slipper did not fit as well and seems that the right slipper is not made as well .

I bought these slippers October 2024 (a bit over a year ago) and I LOVED them at first. Over time, they have stretched out width-wise. They don't stay on my feet anymore. Maybe if they were available in a narrow width? Also, the lambswool lining has discoloration...I can live with that, but it does make them look dirty. I only wear indoors.