Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Mcguffey Lace To Toe

Odd sizing, tried 9.5, just a bit small, went to a 10, was almost the like going to an 11, the different was substantial. Ended up returning the shoes.

The Pros - good looking shoe, pairs well with everything from shorts to jeans, Khakis, and some slacks. Cons - the stitching where the tongue meets the body creates abrasion on the little toe. I took it to Europe and by the end of the first day walking, my little toe was nearly bleeding. Unfortunately, this was the only shoe I carried. The only way I could wear it for the rest of my trip was to tape up my little toe. Even with that my toe has developed a callus and it hurts. I've worn many J&M shoes but this is the first time I've had this issue.

I've been wanting a Dark Brown tennis shoe if that's what they are calling it and while this is nice looking it's got a red richness to it that also like"the bad is the shoe is too thin and you can stand on a dime and know if it's heads or tails. No, I don't recommend this shoe.

The shoe that arrived was lighter in color and wasn't darker at the toe like the picture.

The item color was not what was depicted in the photo. I returned but on another note, the shoe was comfortable.

My toes were at the end of the shoe. Very strange. I exchanged them for a larger size. I'll have to wait and see if they fit.

I started with my usual size, tried to wear them but they were huge. Exchanged for a size smaller, fit in length but still sloppy. I was traveling and needed them or I would have just returned them. They are super rough inside and not comfortable to wear. My feet hurt after walking through the airport.

Uncomfortable unfortunately

Too narrow and not a lot of padding for comfort

Runs very wide for a medium. Returned.