Customer Reviews VIONIC Caroll

Cute shoe but it was too big

Can't wear these all day, but they give good arch support, which is what I'm interested in. I needed a pair of black dress shoes without heels and these work. I live in Florida, so I didn't need anything clunky or for long term wear. The fit was true, and comfortable. The arch support wasn't as good as some of the other Vionic's, but that may be because it isn't a 'substantial' shoe and the arch support is much better than other brands for this style of shoe.

This shoe is lavender! Color is not as shown.

This is an improved ballet flat for vionic and I love the new heel shape and the way the heel material sort of wraps your heel. I always seem to slip out of flats, but this style stayed put. The style is cute , but in the end I had to return as the rounded toe shape seemed to aggravate my slight bunion and squinch my toes more than I could handle. I think I need to give up on this style and stick to more squared off toe boxes.

It looks nice in the style to go with a variety of clothing, but didn’t fit well in the length. Vionic says they have great arch support, it was just meh.

So excited when I saw these online. They were just what I was looking for. I have several pairs of Vionic shoes which I’m very happy with. I wanted to love them, but after ordering 3 different sizes, I realized they were just made ... differently. There’s not enough vertical room in the toe box for actual toes. Sadly, the shoes got shipped back.

Generally, my shoe size is a 7 or 7.5. Even in a 7.5, these were a bit too small. The color is exactly what I needed, but I did not love the style enough to spend this much on a size 8.

Moderately attractive shoe, but dramatically too wide. I am normally a narrow -medium, and ordered a medium. The shoe was way too wide, literally nothing to hold my foot in. I also thought it was more attractive in the photo than in real life. I buy a lot of flats, ranging from Kate Spade and Tory Burch to Eccos and various old lady style flats. These are the widest I've tried.

It pains me to write this...actual pain! I have a couple pairs of Vionics in different styles and love them. I bought these and love how they look. Wearing them for a minute in my house, I was pleased. However, once I got these outside and onto the pavement, within a block the backs of my heels were rubbed raw and remain so 3 days later. I am so bummed. Otherwise they fit perfectly but the high tab on the heel is a poor design. Now I have shoes that I wore for a few blocks that I can't wear again.

I ordered an 8 medium and an 8 wide to compare. The medium fit. However, I am sending both back because, unfortunately, the arch support was under the heel rather than my arch. I vaguely remember another reviewer stating the same thing... I should have taken note.

I really wanted these shoes to work out for me. The fit was great and it had moderate support but the back of the shoe has a higher part to it that completely cut the back of my feet. It created several cuts. The heel part of the shoe is quite low so it was constantly hitting that part of my foot. So sad. The style is lovely, the pink seems a little too bright, a paper version would be nicer for professional dress.

I love Vionics however I couldn't love these shoes. My heel was too narrow and the shoe kept slipping up. Also, there wasn't much arch support, which is why I buy Vionics. Unfortunately I am sending these shoes back. I'll try something else from Vionic.

I should have returned these. The back rubs my foot, causing blisters. Even moleskin hasn’t prevented the pain.

they look great but the sides are very soft, no support for my pronation so sadly have to return; Re: arch support - there is some but not as much as other vionic shoes I've had so I didn't choose the next choice which would have been Moderate

These lovely shoes fit perfectly and were just what I was looking for until I realized that they don't have the comfortable orthotic fit that I've come to expect in Vionic. The elastic edging was super comfortable and I loved the design and color. But there is absolutely no cushioning under the foot and very little if any arch support. If you're looking for shoes that will be comfortable for walking I'd look for another brand.

I struggled with what to rate this shoe. I don't usually review things, but I thought this was worth sharing. These are the most comfortable flats I have had in a long time. However, the leather is so thin that within the second week of occasional wear, the leather started cracking and disappearing, leaving the textured layer beneath exposed.

Not cute. Comfy, to the point I almost kept them, but nope.

These are comfortable but the material is cheap and after about a dozen wears (normal days shopping, etc.), there are large spots where material is flaking, etc. Very disappointing!

I change my previous review! Wore these around the house a good 5-10min and the heel started the rub. The heel tab is a terrible design. Otherwise the shoe would be great.

The back of these shoes is incredibly stiff and cuts into my heal. I have tried a few times to wear them and break them in but it's too painful. I don't recommend this shoe

These shoes were a but too big and given that they were flats they were sliding off my foot, so I had to return. I also ordered in another color and they were too small. I was disappointed that there was this disparity between the two pairs of shoes, neither of which I could keep. I returned both. Vionic haa great shoes so I'll be ordering a different style, but not the flats.

I like the round toe and the arch support is great. However, these shoes are too wide for my feet so I’ll be returning this pair. I wish they made a narrower width.