Customer Reviews VIONIC Caroll

These had really firm arch support, it was just in the wrong place for my foot. The arch support seemed to start too far back, something I'd read in other reviews. These were definitely the best looking of the orthopedic shoes I tried.

The arch support is excellant! I have a tailor's bunion, so a wide toe box is needed. The width of the tow box met my needs, and the heel fit nicely, but the middle sides gapped. I ordered the tan. The color was a perfect neutral.

I usually wear a 6.5 W. This shoe felt ok initially but with walking its heel rubbed horribly on my Achilles tendon. I tried the 7W and it improved, but not much. Very uncomfortable. I normally like Vionic shoes but am returning both pairs.

Vionic is very close to winning my heart. I’d buy several colors if they only offered my size 10.5 I found the 10 to be too short and the 11 just a bit too wide where my foot flipped out causing a trip risk. Safety first, no shoes for me ;)

The back is too high which rubs and causes blisters to form.

I always wear a womens 6.5. These shoes were long enough to be a 7, and felt very wide. It was a bummer, because they style is good and the arch support felt great.

Nice shoe, but toe box was not wide enough for me. Also, I wish there was more arch support.

Definitely not what I thought I would be getting. In person, the styling is not flattering. The toe box is oddly narrow and the heel high and cuts in. The arch support and comfort was not that great either - disappointed and returning.

I was looking for a go-to flat for leggings, skirts, etc. This shoe would have been perfect, but it was way too wide for me. I tried my regular size and a half size smaller to no avail. Sadly they both had to go back.

i wear and 8.5 in aetrex shoes and so to be safe i ordered an 8 and a 8.5. the 8 was a little snug but in the 8.5, my feet were swimming. I reordered an 8 wide but for some reason they left a little longer and my heel was slipping. I am currently ordering a 7.5 wide to see how that goes

I also own this ballet flat style shoe in black in a size 8W. Naturally, I ordered an 8W in pink, but sadly, it ran smaller than the black shoe. Sadly, while both seem to be the proper width, the pink shoe felt more like a 7.5, or 7.75, but not as long as my size 8 black shoe. So, I have to return it. The materials appear to be well made, but the arch isn't quite there, in my opinion. Additionally, I must say, I've had my black pair for quite some time now, but I rarely wear it. Why? The rubber material they use for this sole wears quite quickly. As a flat, you're not aware of it as you slip it on and off until you carefully inspect it.

I was very excited to get the shoes because all the other reviews were so high. Unfortunately for me, these did not work out very well. I got the shoes according to the VIONIC website shoe size chart. I am normally a 40.5-41, so I got these in a 9, but I should have gone with my normal US shoe size which is a 10, or maybe 9.5. I think the 9.5 might have fit. The width was pretty good, but the molded footbed was still too narrow for me. I guess I have really wide feet. My bad, not VIONIC's. The style looks cute on the website, but on my big wide feet, it's not as cute. Oh well. I'll have to try another style and size, but impressed by the footbed. I hope it is better on the next style I try.

The heel is high and rubs your heel even after worn in. Previous vionics wore much better and lasted longer. Unfortunately these were not worth the high price paid.

Shoes fit true to size. Loved the arch support and the style is cute without feeling or looking bulky. I have mild bunions and this shoes felt great. The reason I returned was the back of the shoes, which is not padded. It gave me blisters even with inside the house trial wear. I could have tried with heel liners, but for the price i didn't feel like it. Maybe if it goes on sale.

I really like these shoes, but for some reason, my feet make an inappropriate noise when I walk in them. Since I would be wearing these at work mostly, I can't really walk around making ridiculous (although funny) noises. So unfortunately they have to go back.

Nice shoes. Fit was great. Excellent arch support But they squeak! So I returned them. Nobody wants squeaky shoes. Not sure why. Wish they’d fix it. I’d buy lots.

Really wanted to like/keep these shoes! I have a bunion and these shoes provided enough stretch and comfort which I was thrilled about. The challenge as another reviewer mentioned is the high back which rubbed alot against both feet while I walked around the house so I had to send them back.

Cute shoe but I think they may be misclassified. I found them by searching under "comfort" shoes, but I have to say the inside padding is more average than comfort. It's too bad because the color and style are very cute. Sadly returning.

Nice flat with good arch support. Unfortunately it is way too wide for my feet so it is going back.

My feet typically are a perfect 8-Wide for Vionic. Unfortunately, the toe box is a tad too narrow & flat on these shoes, pressing down on my big toes. The rest of the shoe seems to be perfect. Since the top of the shoe is flat, I am hoping that the leather will mold around my big toes, you can clear see a nub in the leather where my big is trying to poke through because the leather on these shoes is very soft. My big toes curve up a bit, and I typically wear through the big toe on canvas shoes due to the rubbing of the toe nail.

The jury is still out on these flats for me. They are the most supportive ballet flats I have ever found, but they are not perfect. The heel slips a bit, but I don’t feel I should size down because the toe box already feels a little cramped (feels too tight top-to-bottom, as though it’s pushing down on my big toe). Maybe with time, the toe area stretches some? I do like the arch support, and the style is super cute.

The shoe was as soft as a glove. Not so the back, where I developed blisters on both feet. Hard and rough. Very disappointing.

The lip on the back of the shoe was hard and uncomfortable, irritating my foot in all the wrong places. The look of the shoe is great, as well as the impeccable arch support -- I think it's the best (beats my Tory Burch, Cole Haan and more). I returned because of the discomfort of the back lip and that they ran too large. I exchanged for a different Vionic flat.

Fortunately, the shoes are comfortable because they’re somewhat clunky. But comfort was what I sought.

I own other pairs of Vionic brand shoes, and needed a pair of flats for an upcoming trip , so was looking forward to get a nice supportive pair. While I liked the look of these shoes, I had ordered a size 7 1/2 and a size 8, however, both sizes were much too wide. I normally wear a medium width, but these were very wide, so both pair had to be returned.