Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Garret Waterproof Boot

I love the boots but they are really narrow. I have narrow feet but they still seem to fit a little too tight. I'll give it some time, maybe they'll loosen up after I break them in.

I am so in love with my boots. They are very comfortable.

It's pretty but the shoes don't fit well. The front end is empty because the making of the shoes prevent your foot from going all the way in which cause the heel side to be extremely tight and not comfortable to walk. I'm hoping wearing it more can loosen it up a bit.

These boots are really cute on and I received a lot of compliments when I wore them however, they were a bit heavy for me. I had knee surgery recently and I was very fatigued after walking around in them for a couple of hours.

super tight. I love this brand and it's very frustrating that most sizes are only for very narrow feet. I wear regular sizes from other brands and it fits me well. Those are beautiful boots. the zipper is super hard.

I bought the brown Garret Combat (and the Black Dalis Chunky Sole Short Boot). I'm between an 8-8.5 with moderately wide feet, and I ordered the 8.5. My foot appeared to spill out from sides. The leather is soft so I think it would have stretched, but I wish it came in wide. Another deciding factor that made me return the Garrets, was the thin brown strip between the base of shoes and sole. I would have preferred a clean look, and it made it look cheap.

I loved these boots, they are very stylish and comfy,but they're made of cheap material that were showing a sighs of cheap quality and because it was so bad I had return them. I wish they were made of leather which gives the best quality.

Cute but not comfortable. Stylish but not meant to doing a lot of walking. The insole hurts the arches of the feet. It is weirdly shaped. Pretty disappointed since they were expensive.

First pair was great! The second pair was a lemon!

It's a nice style but the color looks different in person, it's lighter than on the pictures. Boot is too narrow for my feet and the heel part rubs against my heel. Unfortunately will have to return.

I love them! I think they may be a little too big for me, I usually wear 8.5 and there is a LOT of room in those boots, but it just leaves room for an extra pair of socks on a cold day! They look stylish and elegant, yet edgy at the same time.. and they feel like walking on clouds! Definitely will repurchase again (please don't discontinue ) The only slight negative feedback I have, is that the color comes off a little bit when I wipe them. I would recommend using black shoe polish or something of the sort so keep them soft and shiny :)

I bought my usual size (7). I couldn't even get my foot in it. Returned and got 7.5s. Still too small. And because I was so discouraged by how ridiculously small they were, I was stupid and didn't try the 7.5s on until it was too late to return them. So, go up at least one full size (I haven't bought the 8s, so can't say one full size is sufficient), if you want these boots.

I had high hopes, but these boots did not meet my expectations. Upon trying on, they seemed to be comfortable and cute. Once I wore them the first time for a few hours, they were very uncomfortable around the ankle. I should have bought the slip-on version of this shoe. The lace up portion of the shoe is just so uncomfortable. Unfortunately after one wear, these will collect dust in my closet until I donate them to charity.

Came with defect on one boot. You can see it badly Must return

I love love loved these boots, but they broke so soon after purchase. I wish they held up better. Both soles cracked under the ball of my feet, which makes me think it's a construction/design issue, not a fluke. Huge bummer.