Customer Reviews Naturalizer Maxwell

I keep sticking out with Naturalizer I wear a solid 10 So far, with this brand, depending on the shoe i can be a 10,10.5, or 11. Bought these in a ten that was waaaaay too tight so returned them and was happy to find they had an 11 in stock (didn’t think the 10.5 would work). The 11 fit well but after a day of office walking I had blisters on my heel because the 11 was just a smidge loose. I tried again with a very thin no show sock and it still didn’t work. I’m certain the 10.5 would’ve been too small. Now that they are worn and I can’t return them they will be donated. Same happened w a 2” Naturalizer pump I bought last year (bought 10 as well as 11 and returned 10 only to get blisters w the 11). But bought a 3.5 “ heel in size 11 last month and they are perfect. Have you pairs of Naturalizer 10s in my closet that are great. It seems to be hit or miss.

These are very nice shoes,however the top of the shoe was a bit tight on the top of my foot.

The fit and size are fine. Wish the toe was a little more tapered for a more business look, but only alternative was the super pointy toe.

Show is well made. The bottoms are supper slippery. No arch support.

I liked the shoe. However, the width was too wide although it was ordered as narrow :(

Somebody said it ran large, so I bought an 8.5 instead of a 9 (most of my shoes are size 9, but some are 8.5). The 8.5 was too small. Although my feet are on the narrower side, I have bunions, and the shoes were pinching them. Might try a 9 wide if others I ordered don't fit well.

Nice shoe, just a bit too narrow across forefoot. Wish it came in Wide Width.

Need them to stretch out a bit over my bunions but otherwise they are just what I need.

My foot is 8.125” long and I typically wear a women’s 3.5. I ordered these in a 4M and they are tight both length and width wise. Have ordered in a 4.5M. Will see how they fit. Cute shoe. Like that they are leather. No arch support at all.

I like the style, but the shoe is too big - a tad too long and definitely too wide.

It was a little tight over the upper toe box area, otherwise would have fit me.

The shoes looked lovely but the wide width was too narrow to wear. I would order a double wide if they had them.

I was so pleased that the black suede flats fit so comfortably when they arrived. I walked for a couple hours in them today and they felt great on my feet. I would happily order a second pair in another color, but you are out of stock of 7N in other colors. Hope you will restock. I wish they were a came down a little lower in the front of the foot, but overall they look pretty good.

Super cute but the top was cutting into my foot. Too bad...

My feet are hard to fit. I need wide at the balls of my feet due to bunions but more narrow at the heels. This cut of shoes slipped too much in the heel. Seems like all I can wear is shoes with ties. Not always fashionable.

I really liked these shoes. They are comfortable, stylish and I absolutely love the color. The inside is a tiny bit stiff for me but I feel like the will break in without a problem. I would definitely recommend them!

Ordered my usual 10 M in Golden Maple Suede. The shoe is crafted so nicely inside and out except that the color for of each shoe - and not because they are suede - does not match the other. It is a subtle mismatch, but I know I'd never wear them. This is not the first time I've received shoes which have color matching issues; reminds me of the MADtv "Lowered Expectations" skits. I am 99.9% sure this was the shoe I used and wasted my $30 off coupon on. Not happy about that either.

Great right out of the box. I wore them to work, where I am on n my feet all day, and came home still loving them. Highly recommend.

Needed a new nude shoe for work clothing. Looks classy and simple. Goes easily with many of my work clothing and is comfortable all day.

I had high hopes that this style might fit my very narrow feet (heel), but alas, a swing and a miss once again. For people with wider feet, I can tell it would be a very comfortable shoe.

A little tight in the toe areas right out of the box.