Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Cody Wing Tip Zip Boot

These boots gave me the worst blister I've ever gotten from a pair of shoes. The foot rides too high with the insoles in. Good thing you can remove them. Hard as a rock without them, but at least the heel doesn't rub on the inside of the boot. They look good tho.

Shoe runs small. I order many shoes from your brand all in 11.5 and never had a problem. I have to return these as they are too small.

Shoes are too long from the front making it look like clown shoes. One of loops broke while trying them on. Had to return. Disappointed with this pair because I wear J&M brand's other shoes and they are fantastic.

These are brown. Not tan as described

Looks good. Sole too hard. Hurt your feet. Thr order is fine. Not a good shoe.

I had to return them . The tongue ripped / tore almost in half when I initially pulled the boot on for the first time . I'm addition the heel was not comfortable.

I have this same shoe in brown and it is a different fit and material. The black is narrower, tighter, and the leather feels different

Received Beautiful boot Wore one time and side seam split Need to return

I sent the boot back, it looked reconditioned.

I have had these boots for about a year. While I frequently wear them, I just wear them to the office so they do not really have heavy use. After about 6 months the outer sole split in the flex area around the midfoot. Very disappointing. I really had high hopes for these boots. They look very nice.

The heel fell off with less than 10 wears (light wears). I made customer service aware and they have been no help. Very disappointed in product quality and customer service. The saying "you get what you pay for" is not the case in this instance. One positive, they were beautiful when they were in one piece!

Too wide and loose fit. Nice looking.

Boot lace hook has already ripped off.

First time I wore the boots the top eyelet broke off. Now there is no metal for the shoelace, just a hole in the leather. That last eyelet is actually a wrap around one, not one that the lace goes through. It is a bit of a design flaw. I bought the boot's specifically for the zipper feature. The way you wear these type of boots is to set and tie the laces and then only use the zipper for easy on and off. With the wrap around eyelet, when you unzipped the boots and remove, the laces come off the wrap around making you re-tie the each time anyway. Bottom line, day one, broken boot. On a bright note, I have similar boots from J&M with a different eyelet system. Awesome boots.

I saw reviews that the heel on this particular type of boot falls off. I naively thought that Johnson and Murphy would fix this issue since the review was written a while ago. The first day I wore these boots, the right boot heel peels off.

Bought these in November and the heel fell off. What looks like wood seems to be actually compressed paper. Bad design for sure!

I returned the shoes because they were obviously used and will never shop with you all again because of this issue. I was mailed used shoes during a pandemic. And no compensation was offered.

The heel area is very stiff and uncomfortable