Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Vintage Slub Polo

Fit is too casual and a bit frumpy. Prefer a more athletic cut.

Nice shirt poorly made

This shirt looked good on my husband. He's only worn it once. But it looks like he's had it for a year because there's already fraying at the collar and pulls on the body of the shirt. It's so soft, but it really didn't hold up well after only one wear/wash.

They look good. I have them in almost every color. Comfortable fit. Almost disposable. After a couple of washes even on gentle cycle, they start coming apart at the seams. I wear them in the house to lounge around so at first tear I just throw them out and get a new one (disposable).

This is my favorite shirt. It's very comfortable and hangs great. I keep buying them over and over. So why does it rate only three stars? Because the fabric doesn't last long at all. I've thrown two away because of fraying at the edges, and three because of holes that formed below the stitching at the bottom of the neckline. My best guess is that they last about 30-40 wears apiece.

I've bought a lot of these shirts (i.e. spent a lot of money). Love almost every thing about them. I don't like that after a few wears and washes they start to break down, especially the collar. They also wear thin and develop holes in other places.

I bought one-of these shirts to try, loved it and ordered 2 more. Unfortunately while packing a travel bag that had a Velcro flap my shirt bumped against the flap and snagged very easily. I'm not sure what to do about the shirt but will be very careful with the other two?

The shirt is very comfortable and looks nice. However, the material frays very quickly. I wash in washer machine and hang dry.

Love this polo! great fabrication, fit and style. Unfortunately after a few washes the shirt begins to fall apart at the placket and shoulder seams

These shirts do not wash well. The collar frays after washing. I order replacement shirts and hand wash them.

As I said above the piping around the inside neck of shirt is sharp and scratchy. Though it does give decorative appear it is un comfortable. Fabric is very nice, light and drapes well. Bought two shirts and really getting a lot of uses from them.

I would love the shirt if the head/neck opening wasn't so small. I can't even put the shirt on without removing my glasses. What's worst of all is that when you tilt your head downwards a slight amount, the front edges of the collars rub under your chin. It's a shame, as the fabric feels great but is sized for pinheads.

Too tight... Expected "D" comfort. Great look, however.

We had to return both shirts because the Size L ran too small and did not fit.

I bought two of these shirts and they fit me perfectly. Unfortunately, the collar is completely shredded by beard stubble after just two uses. I shaved before wearing them and everything. It's very disappointing to know that you can only wear this shirt a couple of times before it looks too ratty to go out in public. I feel like this was a total waste of money. I highly recommend adding a more durable material to the inside of the collar to prevent this from happening to others.

I've bought 2 of these shirts a bit over a year ago and already the shirts have gotten holes in them and starting to fall apart. I expect high quality polos to last much, much longer. Otherwise, I liked the shirts, the size, fit and comfort.

The material obviously picks easily as having only worn once the black one has a pill on the front of it. Runs small

I ordered an XL and the length of the shirt compared to that of a large and sleeve length to that of a medium. The colors and style were great but the shirt size did not match any other XL polo I owned when laid side by side.

Less than 1 year of easy wear only in warm weather (so less than 6 months of actual wear) holes have developed under the placket and under the collar. Style and comfort are great but that does not make up for the holes. Shirt has turned into a fishing shirt not a work shirt. Do not buy if you want any kind of longevity

Too much shrinkage. Won't buy again

I been a fan of your brand, have 4 different pair of shoes, and have bought about 10 Polo shirts, but there are hole in the bottom of the placket, and in the seams of the shoulders, you need to check that prior to send your products to the stores, because I use to be a fan of this brand, not anymore

Looks great and very comfortable BUT, fabric pics and tears away from seam easily. Need to be hand washed. Save your money.

I have 3 of these shirts. The first 2 quickly developed holes at the base of the button area stitching. The 3rd lasted longer but has now formed the same hole. It's too bad because I loved the shirts - comfortable, perfect out of the wash. You really need to stop selling these if the defect cannot be fixed. I see many are having the same problem.

Was disappointed with the fit. Very boxy. Not a modern polo fit, more like something from the older generation.

Shirt was good quality but the fit was terrible. It was too short and too wide at the waste.