Customer Reviews Aetrex Carly

THe peach color is quite bright; not for me. They run small, but all sneakers do. I've ordered the next size up.

i really wanted these to work. I needed a size in between. the 10 was too big and the 9 to 9.5 was just a little too snug on my big toe.

Nice shoe, total comfort--no complaints on structure, style, materials--everything including the fit is perfect and I will look at this brand again. I opted for a slip on instead of a lace up.

Feels like the shoe is hugging my foot. Very supportive for walking, though at least initially, my heel would rub the back of the shoe quite a bit. love the appearance though.

I returned them, Zappos recommended a size too big and while looking I found a different brand I liked better. these are okay cute, they really look like these super cheap shoes I got a Walgreens one year so definitely nothing exciting, just supportive I guess. If you want something more stylish check out Vionic.

The arch felt like it was in wrong place for me.

I have the same shoe, same size in another color. This one fit smaller!

It fit mostly, but my heal slipped in a major way. I returned them.

Did not like the material & fit at heel

I love the look of this shoe. I usually wear a 9M or 9W. I ordered the size 40 and it was huge- even with custom orthotics. I decided to try the 8.5 and my toe came to the end of the shoe. I am really disappointed. I had hoped to add a pair in gray and another pair in white to my wardrobe. The search continues.

I wear Aetrex sandals in a size 8.5. Many of the reviews said to order up, a 40, in this shoe. I did and my foot swims in it. Going to exchange for a 39. Here’s hoping.

I tried two pairs of Aetrex shoes: These, the Carly and one more. They just didn't feel comfortable on my annoyingly problematic feet. Give them a try, they might work for you!

These shoes made my feet super hot! I had to stop waking and take off my socks. Also, the arch support is only moderate for me because the arch sits back too far towards the heel. I need more support in the middle and through ball of my feet. I did not care for the extra inch of sole sticking off the back. It looks weird, make my feet look extra big and seems to make my gait awkward and not a smooth roll as I stroll.

Wanted to love the shoe but the arch support is too far back by the heel to fit properly. Does not fit like the Sandals with the aligned arch support. Otherwise super cute shoe!

I ordered these sneakers for an upcoming trip, based on my experience with the Aetrex Jillian sandal, which is wonderful for my chronic plantar fasciitis. I wear a size 10 (or European size 41) in virtually all shoes, including the Aetrex Jillian, so was surprised when the Carly size 10/41 was decidedly too small. My toes bumped right up against the end of the shoe. I exchanged them for an 11/42, but those were really big. Guess a half-size up would have worked, but isn't available. Otherwise, the arch support that I so need seemed great, and they don't look too bad, either. Gray color was nice. Should work for someone else.

Not at all comfortable. No cushion and little arch support

This shoe does not have a separate tongue like most sneakers. The slip on style was too tight across the top of my foot.

I really wanted to like these - but they are way too wide and since there is no tongue, it is a little hard to get them on. Felt mushy, although the insole is a very good one. Unfortunately, due to the sizing, I have to return.

I was unable to get past the arch support issue. It hit at the bony part of the ball of my foot and there was no getting used to that. Everything else looked good and it would have been a comfy shoe otherwise.

Nice shoes, but note that the laces are merely ornamental. This is a slip on shoe so if you loosen the laces, it won't make the shoe fit more loosely.

Very bummed that I couldn't even get my foot into the shoe. My arch was too high and the tongue of the shoe was attached to the sides, so that there was limited 'give' for my foot to get in. I'd done so much research since I have metatarsalgia/arthritis on the top of my foot - but really can't give a true evaluation since I couldn't get into the shoe.

I didn't feel these where as comfortable as my previous pair was a few years ago

The sole is OK but the upper doesn't look/feel sturdy and there is no reinforcement where the big toe comes in contact with the fabric. I expect the shoe will look worn very quickly.

As others have mentioned, the placement of the arch support is all wrong. I don't know who's feet these were meant to fit. Save yourself the aggravation, don't order them.

I have several pairs of Aetrex and these just aren't up to par. The arch support looks good but somehow doesn't provide the same support as some of their other shoes. The bigger issue is these shoes don't breathe as much as I thought they would. Even though they are a 'relaxed' fit shoe, the heel slides a lot- poor fitting. For some reason after I wear these, my heel aches. Wish I would have returned them before giving them multiple wears- I just kept thinking they'd work out.