Customer Reviews Aetrex Libby

I purchased these because I am not a fan of wearing shoes but living in New England makes them a necessity ;) So I opted for some slip ons so that I could be as comfy as possible. These definitely are now my go to shoes. I like the look of them (I don't like flashy/bedazzled shoes). They are super comfy (a little large feeling - but I wear with heavy socks). The supports on the inside are terrific and "airy" feeling. If I can't wear flip flops in the snow then these are the next best things in my opinion!

This wasn't my first choice for a slip on shoe, but after the other pair I ordered didn't feel comfortable and were returned, I ordered this pair. I'm not as fond of the looks, not crazy about the wide, braided strap, but the comfort level is tops. Very nice for slipping into to run errands for those of us who don't wear our outdoor shoes inside. Will likely order them in black too. This is my first pair of shoes in this brand.

Aaaaaaaaah, a cooling and refreshing oasis from the fire raging underfoot...and under heel. Killer case of plantar fasciitis. Proper size, perfect fit, nice color, great support, stylish shoe, and cooling balm. What is there not to like about this shoe? I love everything.

I tried them on & they feel great. Only bad thing is the top of the right shoe, toward the middle of the shoe near the braid, has a good size scratch approx. 1/2 an inch long & the left shoe on the toe has a small scuff. Makes me think they have been worn & then returned. I love the Libby clog...wanted it in taupe, but they were sold out so, I got the brown & then they have this problem. I may be returning them due to the scratch & scuff. I thought they were expensive before buying, but liked the style so much I bought them anyway. With the scratch & scuff they are too expensive to keep. I guess I can chalk this up to my severe OCD& I sure hate that. I do LOVE the Aetrex brand shoes for comfort & support. You just can't go wrong with Aetrex brand.

I wear an 8-1/2 or 9 depending on the shoe. I ordered both and kept the 9. The 8-1/2 was a little short for my foot. This is the most comfortable clog that I have ever owned. I had one pair of UGG clogs that fit similar a few years back. I prefer clogs but sometimes they make my hips hurt. I love these. I ordered a second pair because I loved them so much.

While online description is accurate, the attached tag states anti-microbial insole. A detail that checked all the boxes for me. I appreciate previous reviews that reported a generous fit because I normally order 10.5W or 11M, the Libby 10.5/11M fits me perfectly. The black leather is polished and substantial. Toe box is roomy, can wiggle toes. The shape of the sole along with arch placement improves my posture while standing. I also like the lower 1" heel height. Pleased with construction and fit. A keeper.

This Aetrex Libby slip-on is well-made and comfortable. Aetrex has a pretty decent arch support but this shoe has a removable insole, and the shoe will actually accommodate my orthotic. The orthotic stays in place and doesn't work its way out as I've had happen with other slip-ons. It is a little roomy with lighter socks. but I think the next size down would be too small. There is some adjustment to tighten it a little.

The length as spot on. I felt it was a little wider but ok for me since my foot is a little wider but not wide enough to order W. The leather is so soft and supple that it does not irritate areas of the foot that are hurting. The style is what attracted me in the first place. The arch support is excellent.

I think you should invest in quality control. Each shoe received was a different size. Have to send them back. I am unable to rate a shoe that wasn't sent in my size.

I wear a size 9W, and have bunions. The shoe fit nicely, it fit my foot well, and is very soft and cushiony inside, but had an arch support. I can see my putting these on to run errands, or just around the house.

Zappos recommended a size 7.5/8 based on previous shoe history purchases. In this shoe my large toe is right up against the inside of shoe edge. My heel fits in the heel well very good but with my toe hitting on edge inside a little tight. I kept shoes because I did not purchase to do long walks in. I bought for wearing with thick socks inside of house and taking my dogs out for potty breaks in rain and keeping the top of my feet dry. I have been wearing now for about 2 weeks and they have stretched a little in toe length and they feel better. When watching TV always kick off my shoes.

Fit well, but immediately felt foot drop and twist- not supportive

Nice shoe, total comfort--no complaints on structure, style, materials--everything including the fit is perfect and I will look at this brand again. Living in an urban environment I want to be certain of the shoe staying on my foot in any situation so I opted to return these. They also made my foot look a bit flat so I decided against them. It was a tough call because they are a great casual shoe that is well made.

Too short, so I felt the lip on my heel

Size was fine. Arch and heel were super comfortable. The toe area needs more cushion. Had that been the case, I would not have returned them. And unfortunately, the pair I received were somewhat visibly broken in from someone else. Little disconcerting.

These clogs didn't cling to my feet when I walked around in them. They were uncomfortable and noisy., so I decided to keep looking.

I wanted to love these, BUT, I walked right out of them! Couldn't keep them on even for one step! It felt like I was wearing men's shoes... So, they're going back.

Not enough cushioning for the ball of the foot. Just didn't work for me.

stiff, uncomfortable, very little arch support, unattractive

The fit was ok, but a little wide and sloppy. Very uncomfortable and zero arch support.

The fit was ok, a little wide and sloppy fitting. They were very uncomfortable and had zero arch support.

I love Aertrex shoes, but these are the worst style I have ever purchased. The insole is some type of foam, that at first felt very comfortable. However, when you walk, your foot bounces and it gives no arch support and because the top of the shoe is roomy your foot slides forward every step you take. Returning.

It does not fit my bunions. The forefoot was too tight, but would be fine for someone else.

This shoe was a little too short, I need a size 7, not 6.5. It is beautiful and very well made, hope I a size 7 is available.

After sending back 10 pairs (Thank you Zappos for this service) I finally found a great shoe that accommodates all my aches and pains and medical problems. Cute and nice enough to wear for business casual. I'm not used to walking in clogs, I don't think i would want to go on a hike with them, but great for walking around in the shop and at home.