Customer Reviews Merrell Yokota Polar Waterproof

I bought this one with the Columbia Ice Maiden II, knowing I would only keep one. I test both around the house. The Ice Maiden was a touch warmer (rated 200 g insulation), but the Merrell's were comparable. I like how most of the foot is covered with the synthetic non-waterproof part with the Merrells. Easy to slide on and lace up. Fit was true to size. No pinching, even when wearing thick wool socks. More room in the foot bed in this one for my bunion. Arch support is moderate but could easily accommodate an orthotic if needed. I kept these over the Ice Maiden because I though the Merrell's would be easier on my feet for winter hiking. It kept my feet toasty on my first 3 mile hike in 25 degree snowy weather. Grip is decent for average snow. I would recommend using yak tracks or spikes if you will be walking in areas of solidly packed down snow or black ice. Snow slides off the synthetic part. Feet stayed dry.

According to a friend that worked in the outdoor industry for many years, I have a “low volume” foot – meaning it is not considered a “narrow”, but it is on the slim side. Merrells tend to fit my feet well. I tried on both the 9 and 9.5 and went with the 9. The 9 is snug but still comfortable with room in the toe box. The 9.5 felt a little too roomy. If I had a fleshier foot, I could see where the 9.5 might be a better fit. I suggest trying your size and the next half-size up. The insole feels a little intense, but I called Merrells and they told me it will form to my foot with wear.

I am normally a size 9, but the 8.5 is perfect. Definitely size down half a size. Super lightweight and comfortable!

This makes my size 11 feet look like Cinderella‘s dainty things. Super comfortable right out of the box and warm. Easy to lace and very lightweight. I wore them sledding w my niece and they were so cozy and had great traction for climbing back up the hill. Look forward to wearing all winter in CO.

I love these boots! I bought this boot for when I travel to cold places and for the few days a year Dallas gets show. The boot is lightweight, comfortable, and seems durable. I like that the faux fur top is minimal so I can wear these with boot cut or straight leg jeans as well as skinny jeans if I want. I can’t comment yet on how warm or waterproof they are because I haven’t had a chance to test them. But so far, they meet everything I was looking for, including muted colors.

Terrific boots! Warm and comfortable.

I like these boots - warm and comfortable.

Very comfortable and warm!