Customer Reviews SOREL Whitney™ II Short Lace

Loved the look of this Boot. Felt tue to Size. Was a slim fit for a medium width, but this was good with me as I normally wear a narrow (AA) width. I found the toe box of the right shoe to be uncomfortable for some reason. Unfortunately, I was unsure if it would get better, so I returned. them

These were comfy and warm, however, the toebox was too narrow for me. I usually wear an 8.5 in regular shoes, 9 in running shoes and boots so I ordered a 9 in the boots. A 9.5 might have accommodated the hiking socks I want to wear, but I didn't want to chance it with how narrow they were.

The Sorel size chart supplied here is delusional, haha! My feet are 9.75 inches long. The size chart says I am an 8, but I am a 10.5 (maybe even 11 for sock room) in these booties. The color is not quite as expected—here it looks a fun pumpkin orange, but they are less vibrant, more warm brown in person. Bummer on that. I wish they came in more colors. They are super comfortable in general, NO digging into the Achilles like many boots do. They make a slight crispy/crunchy sound like a sleeping bag or windbreaker, but not too bad. If you have high arches like me, you'll want to swap out or supplement the footbed for better support, as these give that "all the pressure is on the outer half of the foot" feeling under the mid-foot, which can lead to a world of pain. I do have slightly long/narrow-ish feet, so the width is perfect for me, but I can see how people with average or wider feet might find them a smidge narrow. I have sensitive toes and like a roomy/wide toebox, though, and these do not constrict or press on my toes at all.

Fit well. Liked the arch support. A little tight across the top. Have to wait to see how they will do in the snow.

I really wanted to like these boots. They are nice looking and felt fine but after wearing them awhile at home my lower back started to hurt, that's why I gave it a 3 for comfort. There is something about the pitch of them that didn't agree with my back, sadly. Otherwise I would have kept ,they are cute and seemed like they would be warm. I think they were true to size.

The jury is still out on these boots. I LOVE the style and they are comfortable. They do run narrow so had to order 1/2 size larger. For some reason, they kind make you look as if you have skis on your feet, they are so narrow. I'm worried about the water resistance since they are just fabric. I feel like these would be good to run around and do errands in during the winter, but may not want to shovel snow in these. I personally haven't worn them in snow yet so I can't speak for the warmth/water resistance. Super cute style though!

I ordered a half size up and it was too large.

Great boot comfortable and flexible

These boots looked cozy and they were, they're not ugly or slunky looking. But.. they're absurdly narrow. Tried the 7.5 and then the 8. Still too narrow, had to give up on em'. Narrow toeboxes are a bad idea.

These are very cute boots. Exactly what I was looking for. I sized up to 8.5, I usually wear a size 8 in shoes. With medium thick hiking socks these fit nicely. They feel like sneakers. There is not much for arch support but they are very comfortable. I tried Ugg boots and Sorrel with no luck. These boots fit great. They are supposed to be waterproof and warm but I have yet to wear them in snow or rain.

I was really looking forward to these boots. Loved the look and style. Upon arrival I immediately opened the box and put the right boot on. It was incredibly short and uncomfortable - not really sure if 1/2 size or full size smaller. But definitely not a standard size 7. I have worn a size 7 in all styles of footwear for at least 3 decades and was disappointed that I had to return them.

Super cute HOWEVER super narrow. I'm 7.5 and got an 8. Let's see if this will stretch out a little bit but SOREL should plan thei designs taking in consideration the thicker socks we have to use in such freeze/cold weather. Makes no sense....

Great looking boot and yes a bit narrow but just too short for my needs.

I already had these boots in the Elk color. I decided to get the grey to go with a grey NF winter parka. We finally got snow so I was able to try them out. Warm and toasty. Comfortable to walk in. When sitting something inside the boot rubs on the side of my foot. This is why 4 stars. I am an 8.5 sometimes a 9. I got these in a 9 and the fit is good. Overall a good purchase and they will keep your feet warm.

I love these boots, just need a bigger size. The upper par of the boot is very soft and cushioned..not stiff or uncomfortable.

I’m a solid 9 in everything. On the advice of another review to order a full size up I found the 10 WAY too large. But I do think a 9.5 is the way to go to wear thick socks. Runs slightly small.

Very cute and seems warm but runs very small. I would’ve exchanged for a larger size but the size was not available. Unfortunately, I ended up having to return them.