Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Hayes Penny Loafers

Drop down a half of size

The new ones are superb. For some reason or another your 7s are not fitting like the other 7s I have bought in the past. But thats okay because I am trying several methods to make these new ones work. The shoes you make are superb and worked for me for years. Keep it up.

I normally wear a 10 but because my feet are narrow I get 9s for loafers. This has worked well in the past with JM loafers but this pair was considerably larger than my last ones. I put some sticky pads on the heels and wear a little thicker socks and they fit ok. If these were my everyday day shoes I would have returned them. Otherwise, its a quality shoe at a reasonable price.

I normally wear a 10 but because my feet are narrow I get 9's for loafers. This has worked well in the past with JM loafers but this pair was considerably larger than my last ones. I put some sticky pads on the heels and wear a little thicker socks and they fit ok. If these were my everyday day shoes I would have returned them. Otherwise, it's a quality shoe at a reasonable price.

Great shoes. . . wide width runs narrow. . . .

My second pair. Liked the first pair so much I replaced the sole. After 10 years the uppers are showing the wear. It was time for a new pair.

2nd pair of same shoe, love them

I love the clean lines of this classic loafer. Dressed up or dressed down, it is the perfect shoe for my Wardrobe.

Love this style its classic !!

I bought a pair of Johnston & Murphy black loafers. I wore them most days to work. But they have finally lost their strength. Who would have dreamed they would last so long?!!! So I just bought a new pair just like them, and I expect these new ones to last me the rest of my days. Thank you J&M for making such a quality product!

These classic loafers are a wardrobe staple. Look great, versatile. Great price!

A little loose at the heel compared to the last time I bought the same item about a year ago. Size 10. 5 both times. Still love the shoes.

A little loose at the heel compared to the last time I bought the same item about a year ago. Size 10. 5 both times. Still love the shoes.

Well made. Beautiful color. Love the pair!

Well made and very comfortable

The shoes look great and were very comfortable. They were a little stiff initially, but broke in quickly. The one thing I will say , though is that they seem to run a little big. I own 5 pairs of Johnston and Murphy shoes, all are size 11. 5, but these were a little loose fitting. I love the look, though and they should last me for a few years at least. The price was right too.

Great shoes very comfortable and fit is perfect . Love the look with dress pants or jeans. i would bought the black but i will also get the burgundy too. Thanks Johnston & Murphy

Quality leather and great looking at a very reasonable price. Best loafer I found in this category

Look good. Fit well.

Very comfortable

Have bought several loafers from several companies and the fit has been so strange for all them. Finally got this pair and I love them!

Purchased for my son and he loves them. They are super comfortable, stylish. Highly recommend.

Great! Comfortable and good-looking!