Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Hayes Penny Loafers

I wear 10 in Reebok, 10 in adidas superstar. 9.5 in boots. 9.5 for these was the right size

Very good loafers good price I will recommend this shoes.

I want to exchange from 8.5 D to 8.5W…how can I do that?

Very happy with style and fit and value

The fit is perfect! Service & shipping time fantastic!

Fit and size are as stated and shoe is comfortable. Quality leather and treatment and design is what attracted me.

Breaking them in. Still comfortable.

It's almost impossible to find a traditional, classic penny loafer in women's shoes. J & M Hayes are beautiful and well made. I wear an 11 in women's. I'm having trouble finding the right size in these. I need 9W apparently, but there are none available in black.

The shoes fit me and are comfortable to wear.

Shoes look nice, fit well, feel comfortable, I am a happy customer. Recommend this

Fit just as I expected and less expensive than the same pair at Macy's!

Very attractive, comfortable shoe. Fit is true to size.

The shoes look great. Looks nice on my 12 year old. My son is growing so much that his foot got larger, he’s already wearing a men’s size. I will need to exchange for a bigger size

For me, these seemed to run a bit large, but once I found the right size, they were awesome. Beautiful shoe.

nice shoes. I have another pair different color. so I bought the black color. and I am satisfied

Amazing , fast service. Ordered the shoes on Friday night and received them Monday morning.

good fit, excellent material

All I can say is that I’m fully satisfied. I received exactly what I saw in the picture from the apps.

Fit and size of shoes was perfect. Quality of Johnson & Murphy of this traditional loafer is evident.

I ordered a size 14 you shipped 15

Great service and exactly what I wanted.

Perfect fitting, excellent shoe

Good