Customer Reviews Birkenstock Tracy

I love this for a work "flat". It looks cute and professional while being comfortable all day. Good arch support. I was able to get the wide width, which was necessary for me. My foot was wider from a recent injury and arthritis.

I love Birkenstocks. I have too many pairs to count. ? I have been looking for more shoe styles to get me through the cold months. I’m undecided on the style of these. In some ways I think they’re cute and other ways I wonder if I look frumpy (the curse of middle age... gracefully surrendering the things of youth while not sacrificing ones’ true self and also learning not to care IF my heart’s desire for comfortable shoes means my feet look frumpy). I did have to size up to 42 since these only come in the narrow fitting. I’m usually a perfect 41 in Birks.

Opened the box and thought this was not going to work like the last eight pair. Wow! What a pleasant surprise how well this shoe fits. I got the 8-8 1/2W and it fits perfect with just enough wiggle room. The sole is firm and supportive. The top leather is sooooo nice and smooth. Great for my bunions. Also this shoe is so cute on. Beautiful and supportive without being big and clunky. Just bought another pair. Thank-you Zappos!

In my 60s, I have developed problem feet: My size 10 feet got bigger, I developed plantar fascitis, and found out that I actually wear a 10 1/2 narrow! It is very hard to find my size, and also to fit my semi-narrow instep, but very narrow heels. I am so grateful that Zappos carries my size. Of 8 shoes that I ordered, only this pair fits! I have not yet worn these shoes outside the house, but every time I put them on, I feel that they fit me even better, so the shoes are molding to my feet. I am very pleased. I am not sure that they have enough padding for my heels, but my orthotics fit in them, which is a huge blessing. I think they will get even more comfortable as I wear them more.

Very cute shoe, lighter weight than I expected. I am a solid 39N in Birk sandals and clogs, but the right toe box was tight on the sides and I had to take them off after a few minutes. Too bad!

Who knew you could have flat Mary Janes and have arch support too. They're true to size and very comfortable ,as always.

These shoes are wonderful but be warned, the buckle is NOT silver, it is yellow brassy color. I was not happy about this, but it is what it is.

Very cute and comfortable. The footbed is very soft and feels very supportive despite the outer part of shoe appearing very flat. They feel just like my Birkenstock sandals.

When I first tried them on, the arch felt all wrong. My feet weren’t happy—but I noticed my ankles, knees & hips were suddenly way less painful. The footbed has now molded to me and I love wearing these. Better than barefoot!

I usually wear a 39 in Birkenstock sandals, but had to return a pair of these and order a 40 for them to fit comfortably. They are really cute on, wish they came in more colors. Would recommend to anyone.

I love this shoe, but it definitely runs smaller than other Birkenstocks. I have several pairs of Birks and I am always a true size 40 (9-91/2). I ordered a size 40 on 6PM for 30% less but had to return them because they were too small. Unfortunately they were out of size 41, so I paid full price on Zappos. I think the price difference is strange since 6PM is a sister company of Zappos. Too bad Zappos doesn't price match their own sister company! However, I love the shoe and plan to use it for dancing!

Perfect fit for my imperfect feet! I have multiple foot issues that give me a great deal of pain. These shoes are so comfortable from the get go!

I'm a solid sz 11M in most shoes, but I generally size down to a 41 in open-toe Birks. Since these are closed-toe, I decided to go with a 42, and they were a perfect fit. I broke my foot a few years ago and prefer Birks for a little bit extra support, and these were exactly like my sandals. They probably won't win any beauty contests, but they aren't terrible either.

These shoes slipped on the first time like I had been wearing them forever! Very comfortable and stylish! Worth every penny!

I only have a pair of regular sandals and assumed that the sizing was the same in a regular shoe. These were a little smaller and rubbed against my heel causing a blister. My pinkie toes touched the sides and big toe rubbed the top of the shoe. Wish they were a bit roomier like the sandals.

Sizing for these is not the same as sandals. I ordered my usual 40 and I need a 41 -- toes were far too close to the end of the shoe. I really want these, so I'm on a wait list for my size should it ever come back in stock. That said, there was another Birkenstock Mary Jane style they sold a few years ago I liked better. These are okay but less structured than my ideal, and I wish the soles were a darker color. On my feet, these were cute and flattering.

My usual size in Arizona was too small. My toes hit the front. I bought these in a 39 and Gary in a 40 and will be keeping the Gary. The sole here is not as intense as Arizona, but I need that structure and will probably spend a lot of the winter months wearing my Arizona’s with socks.

This was a repeat purchase. Same shoe, same size too small. In the same order I had a different style of Birkenstocks same size, too big. Returned

Very comfy

Very comfy and cute. Great flats for walking.

Comfie right from the box. The adjustable strap is just perfect for my narrow feet.

Great right out of the box even for my very flat feet. Stylish enough esp. with ballet slipper style being more in currently.

Fits well. I like how adjustable the strap is! I would like it to be a more modern design, but very comfortable

It was too short so will order it the next size bigger. Loved how light it was and hoping to wear then on my cruise in February as both a causal shoe and a dressier shoe since travel space is limited!

Don’t hesitate on these. Perfect Mary Jane type shoe that doesnt look bulky or childish. Good arch support. Strap doesn’t rub top of foot. Plenty of toe room. I sprayed them with a nubick/suede spray to hopefully clean them easily since they’re a light color.