Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy McGuffey Casual Slip-on Sneaker

Cut the back of my foot just above the heal in just a few hours of wear. I would like to return them for

To small and not what I expected

Looking for a replacement for my super-comfy versatile J&M #20-2507 grey Nubuck slip-ons. THESE ARE NOT THEM!

color received was not close to the color represented in the catalog

The left shoe is about 1/4" bigger than the right and feels sloppy.

Honestly, I LOVED my first pair of these shoes, until the sole delaminated from the upper. Now i have received my second pair and i have worn them 4 times, and the right shoe squeaks when i walk. Its very annoying. I would like a refund for these, and i will have to find another shoe manufacturer....

Love the look if the shoe. However, the insole gets detached exposing blue cushion/foam.

I have been a fan of J&M shoes. I purchased my first one at the Nashville Factory Store in 2007 and have only wore J&M since. I have had very good luck with their shoes. But this shoe was a complete waste of money. The show is stylish and comfortable to wear. There is no way to polish & shine the shoe. The white rim around the shoe is chaffed quickly. I would highly recommend NOT to buy these.

Defect in this show. The stitching at the top front causes blister. Have to wear a sock that shows which makes the look quite unattractive. Comfort level is poor.

Purchase in March, wear once or twice a week since, however I already have a hole at my small toe on one of the shoes. Didn't last a short 3 months. Don' t waste your money on this one.

This was a fantastic/comfortable shoe but the shoe box stretched after 15-20 wears and I have to strain my feet to keep them on now! I can longer wear them!

These are some of the cheapest --and I don't mean inexpensive --shoes I have ever bought --had them about a month and the bottom has completely worn out and I don't wear them every day --terrible product --would never buy again

I have 3 pair of this style,the oldest being almost 8 years. The left shoe of this pair is cut too high and blistered the top of my instep in one wearing. Even tried to cushion with moleskin but didn't work. Returned them yesterday

it hurt my knee is too flat

I have had issues with this model . The first one i returned it and exchanged now i have the same issue with the second pair . The right heel toward the right side of the shoe comes unglued . That is because driving the edge of the sole comes in contact withe floor mat of the car. This second pair i wore it only 5 to 7 times only. You need to think of those details when you design your soles. I had an issue with another pair that i returned because the leather finish after wearing it only one time changed . The part were your toes flex the leather changed vs the part that the leather did not flex. Again the shoes look great in the catalog pictures but used no so great. My wife bought a pair for herself and leather faided after few months. I am starting to think that your quality is hit or miss but at your prices that should not be the casa.