Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy McGuffey Casual Slip-on Sneaker

I much preferred the previous version of this shoe that I had. A semi rigid toe cover has been added which makes the shoe MUCH LESS comfortable and rubs on the toes. Bad move JM!

Shoes squeak when walking. I am not sure if its going to stop once they loosen up.

Did not fit, too tight. Not as rich looking in person.

I have these same shoes in black nylon material in size 10.5 but these are too small and hurt my toes. The style of this shoe is great. I wish the sizes were more consistent between the different materials.

Too heavy for a casual shoe.

too small

arch support is too high

I like the style and look of the shoe very much. Like most J&M shoes they are well made. However, this shoe is not as comfortable as I expected therefore the 3-star rating.

Fit well as I have wide feet. I have another pair in black. I returned only to get the perforated version. Recommend J&M would put removable insoles in these so I could use orthotics.

I love these shoes, but I admit to a problem with one of them; it says it's the correct size, and appears to be the correct size, but when I put the shoes on my feet, the left one feels a whole size larger! I'll need to address this with J&M; I believe they'll help resolve this issue with me.

Left shoe was tight and caused an abrasion on my instep. Hope it stretches with wear.

These are the most comfortable shoes that I have owned, however after about 10 wears the woven part on the right shoe is separating from the sole. Now I have an almost new pair of shoes that I can't wear. I would love to recommend these shoes because they are comfortable and stylish, but the quality doesn't match the price.

Very well made shoe, however, it is only offered in a medium width and my husband requires a wider width. He like the shoe, but is unable to wear it because of the width issue.

Honestly, I like your shoes. My husband and son like they are comfortable. However, I have never received even a 10% off for a purchase or immediate discount after so many orders within the past few years.

Like the shoes but the insole has a thin fabric over it that, on the right foot shoe, became unattached after only having worn them twice. Requesting a replacement.

Nice looking shoe, but were too narrow for me. Had to return them. Theydo not come in a wide, as far as I know.

Not much arch support.

Feel flat footed in these.

Glue at sole to upper not holding at flex points. Makes look like coming apart though stitching is holding. 4th pair of these I have had and first time with this issue. Maybe new manufacturing site or materials.

Great shoes. Very comfy. I did get a defective pair but customer service has been working with me. I was fully refunded but will be waiting to see if my request for an exchange is still in process, since instead of a reply, I received an email for a review. I'd love to get this pair again and hope it's still in process.

I hope they made wide size

left shoe rubs on heal and made a blister on 1st wearing.

very comfortable except they don't breathe well and run hot.