Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy McGuffey Casual Slip-on Sneaker

Looks great with jeans or slacks.

Great to wear with jeans

These J&M McGuffeys are essentially "Vans for Grown-Ups." Jeff Spicoli would be rocking' a pair. Why pay more for these instead of buying Vans or a less expensive comparable? The perfed nubuck material on these has to count for something vs. canvas in terms of looks and durability. These have a somewhat sleeker profile vs. Vans. They seem lighter and somewhat more comfortable overall.

Great travel wear...

I enjoy these in every color to go with golf shirts silk shirts, slacks or shorts, all summer long and vacations in the islands etc. They are pricey compared to similar Tommy Bahama shoes but are more comfortable. Watch out for inconsistency in sizing. I had to return the last pair due to size issues. They were size 11 but really the length of 10.5

Like the padding and the style. I would like it better if it came in wide sizes 10.5 Wide. I had to buy the 11.5 for the width to work.

Nice design

My first pair of J&M's and loving them so far. Feels like I'm walking on little clouds and they are nice enough for work. They seem well built but time will tell.

One of the best impulse buys in a while. It's like walking on clouds and they look good too! They seem well built but time will tell.

These stylish shoes are a bit narrower than I expected. (My last ordered shoe products from JM suffered from the same problem). Because these shoes only come in one width size (M), had I known otherwise, I would have ordered them 1/2 to a full size bigger to compensate. Otherwise they are nice looking casual shoes.

Comfortable and stylish. Leather makes foot hot if worn long or in high temperatures

This is a very stylish shoe that works for many occasions. I just wish it was more comfortable. The lining leather is not soft and the shoes lack the flexibility of a really well made one. I've taken to wearing them with socks to help break them in a bit and that's helping, but I shouldn't have to do that.

Looks good- still breaking them in- still a bit tight after a week but I like them

I have a couple of this same style. This pair ran too small. Return process took forever and had to call three time to check on my return status and credit. Disappointed.

I prefer the lighter brown pair I currently have. I'm going to reorder them.

I noticed, after several wears the top of the shoe creases once you start stepping Which has a subtle white look, not very impressive

Great style, comfort. However, even with protective spray, stains absorb deeply and can't be adequately removed.

I love everything about it except the front of the shoes look really wide when you wear it! Looks a lot better online!

Just okay.

They're just not as comfortable as my wooven leather McGuffy slipons

I did not like the fitt

Coloring seems Off from the online photos. Color gradient at the tip is much more pronounced and makes it look cheap.

Very comfortable but I wear a 7 or 7.5 but the good colors don't come on those sizes.